Dd

"Dave"

01/11/2005 4:01 AM

Porter Cable versus Hitachi router opinion wanted.

I have been looking at the PC 694VK and the Hitachi KM12VC routers. Both
have the fixed and plunge bases that come with them. I cannot decide which
one to purchase. Tool Crib has them for nearly the same price. I primarily
will be using it for routing dovetails on my Leigh jig and for misc
operations. I will not be using it in a router table. Which one do you folks
like the best for these operations? The Hitatchi has a 1/2 more HP. I don't
think it would make that much difference for what I want to use it for.
Thanks for your opinions,


This topic has 5 replies

Bi

"Buster"

in reply to "Dave" on 01/11/2005 4:01 AM

01/11/2005 6:50 AM

PC was rated very high is Tauntons tool guide...


"Dave" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:KMB9f.291003$084.220445@attbi_s22...
>I have been looking at the PC 694VK and the Hitachi KM12VC routers. Both
> have the fixed and plunge bases that come with them. I cannot decide
> which
> one to purchase. Tool Crib has them for nearly the same price. I primarily
> will be using it for routing dovetails on my Leigh jig and for misc
> operations. I will not be using it in a router table. Which one do you
> folks
> like the best for these operations? The Hitatchi has a 1/2 more HP. I
> don't
> think it would make that much difference for what I want to use it for.
> Thanks for your opinions,
>
>

AA

Astriapo

in reply to "Dave" on 01/11/2005 4:01 AM

06/11/2005 10:44 AM

Phisherman wrote:

> On Tue, 01 Nov 2005 04:01:46 GMT, "Dave" <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>
>>I have been looking at the PC 694VK and the Hitachi KM12VC routers. Both
>>have the fixed and plunge bases that come with them. I cannot decide which
>>one to purchase. Tool Crib has them for nearly the same price. I primarily
>>will be using it for routing dovetails on my Leigh jig and for misc
>>operations. I will not be using it in a router table. Which one do you folks
>>like the best for these operations? The Hitatchi has a 1/2 more HP. I don't
>>think it would make that much difference for what I want to use it for.
>>Thanks for your opinions,
>>
>
>
> I like the Porter Cable. Since you are not to use it in a router
> table, I'd go with the lighter-weight model which can be easier to
> handle.


And the Porter Cable is very easy to switch bases, also Micro Adjust. I
love mine.

Rd

Robatoy

in reply to "Dave" on 01/11/2005 4:01 AM

01/11/2005 7:01 AM

In article <KMB9f.291003$084.220445@attbi_s22>, "Dave" <[email protected]> wrote:

> I have been looking at the PC 694VK and the Hitachi KM12VC routers. Both
> have the fixed and plunge bases that come with them. I cannot decide which
> one to purchase. Tool Crib has them for nearly the same price. I primarily
> will be using it for routing dovetails on my Leigh jig and for misc
> operations. I will not be using it in a router table. Which one do you folks
> like the best for these operations? The Hitatchi has a 1/2 more HP. I don't
> think it would make that much difference for what I want to use it for.
> Thanks for your opinions,

I used to buy a lot of PC routers. The quality has deteriorated, at least with
their production routers.
The higher failure rate in their bearings, forced me to look at other routers.
I have been very pleased with the M12V in the plunge category and it HAS to be
the best bang for the buck out there.
For the smaller routers, I'm completely sold on the Milwaukee 1516. It takes all
the PC template bushing with an optional base-plate (or you can buy one from Pat
Warner, if you want a very nice one.)
I'm very impressed with the Milwaukee routers. I have 3 now and work them very
hard under less that favourable conditions (solid surface fabrication).
That 5616 runs like a Swiss watch at low RPM..and rated at 2.25 HP..has LOTS of
balls.

The usual caveats..no..I don't work for Milwaukee..not even their breweries.

BI

"Brian In Hampton"

in reply to "Dave" on 01/11/2005 4:01 AM

31/10/2005 11:08 PM

I have the P_C and I like it alot....Brian


--
www.members.cox.net/bsnikitas
"Never Underestimate The Power Of Stupid People
In Large Groups!"
"Dave" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:KMB9f.291003$084.220445@attbi_s22...
> I have been looking at the PC 694VK and the Hitachi KM12VC routers. Both
> have the fixed and plunge bases that come with them. I cannot decide
which
> one to purchase. Tool Crib has them for nearly the same price. I primarily
> will be using it for routing dovetails on my Leigh jig and for misc
> operations. I will not be using it in a router table. Which one do you
folks
> like the best for these operations? The Hitatchi has a 1/2 more HP. I
don't
> think it would make that much difference for what I want to use it for.
> Thanks for your opinions,
>
>

Pn

Phisherman

in reply to "Dave" on 01/11/2005 4:01 AM

06/11/2005 3:25 AM

On Tue, 01 Nov 2005 04:01:46 GMT, "Dave" <[email protected]> wrote:

>I have been looking at the PC 694VK and the Hitachi KM12VC routers. Both
>have the fixed and plunge bases that come with them. I cannot decide which
>one to purchase. Tool Crib has them for nearly the same price. I primarily
>will be using it for routing dovetails on my Leigh jig and for misc
>operations. I will not be using it in a router table. Which one do you folks
>like the best for these operations? The Hitatchi has a 1/2 more HP. I don't
>think it would make that much difference for what I want to use it for.
>Thanks for your opinions,
>

I like the Porter Cable. Since you are not to use it in a router
table, I'd go with the lighter-weight model which can be easier to
handle.


You’ve reached the end of replies