ls

layman

24/11/2005 6:54 AM

sanding soft and hard woods together?

hi, my laminated woodworking project has epai and African mahogany
strips in it. kind of like a butcherboard. No matter how straight a
backing board I use. (I've even tried marble and tile) the softer wood
sands first and I have "dents" where the harder wood is proud. I don't
have access to a thickness sander. Any tips? Thank you.


This topic has 6 replies

Lr

"Leon"

in reply to layman on 24/11/2005 6:54 AM

24/11/2005 3:19 PM


"layman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> hi, my laminated woodworking project has epai and African mahogany
> strips in it. kind of like a butcherboard. No matter how straight a
> backing board I use. (I've even tried marble and tile) the softer wood
> sands first and I have "dents" where the harder wood is proud. I don't
> have access to a thickness sander. Any tips? Thank you.

Like Rob said, a scraper or a smoother hand plane.

RV

"Rob V"

in reply to layman on 24/11/2005 6:54 AM

24/11/2005 7:20 AM

Try using a scraper instead - you should get a more uniform finish.


"layman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> hi, my laminated woodworking project has epai and African mahogany
> strips in it. kind of like a butcherboard. No matter how straight a
> backing board I use. (I've even tried marble and tile) the softer wood
> sands first and I have "dents" where the harder wood is proud. I don't
> have access to a thickness sander. Any tips? Thank you.

ni

"noonenparticular"

in reply to layman on 24/11/2005 6:54 AM

24/11/2005 2:10 PM


"Rob V" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Try using a scraper instead - you should get a more uniform finish.
>
>
> "layman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
>> hi, my laminated woodworking project has epai and African mahogany
>> strips in it. kind of like a butcherboard. No matter how straight a
>> backing board I use. (I've even tried marble and tile) the softer wood
>> sands first and I have "dents" where the harder wood is proud. I don't
>> have access to a thickness sander. Any tips? Thank you.
>
Rob,

I have to respectfully disagree here. I once used a scraper on a row of
mortises (craftsman style piece). The scraper cut a *noticeable* dip over
the mortise.

I would use the handplane in this instance as I *believe* the hard and soft
woods would behave the same given the curved edge a scraper presents.

YMMV
FWIW
MY2CW
ETCETC
AODYCTO

JC
>

Lr

"Leon"

in reply to layman on 24/11/2005 6:54 AM

25/11/2005 1:26 AM


"noonenparticular" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:PRjhf.504>>
>
> I would use the handplane in this instance as I *believe* the hard and
> soft woods would behave the same given the curved edge a scraper presents.


Have you ever used a scraper that had a straight edge vs. a curved one?
Those work a lot like a hand plane.

ni

"noonenparticular"

in reply to layman on 24/11/2005 6:54 AM

25/11/2005 1:42 AM


"Leon" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>
> "noonenparticular" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:PRjhf.504>>
>>
>> I would use the handplane in this instance as I *believe* the hard and
>> soft woods would behave the same given the curved edge a scraper
>> presents.
>
>
> Have you ever used a scraper that had a straight edge vs. a curved one?
> Those work a lot like a hand plane.

Actually I don't own a curved edge scraper (didja hear that Santa? Hint
Hint.....).

However, I always bow mine outward with my thumbs while scraping. That was
the curved edge I was referring to.

Should have said so, but I usually assume everybody is reading my mind. ;-)

jc

Tt

"Tyke"

in reply to layman on 24/11/2005 6:54 AM

24/11/2005 1:43 PM

I think you meant ipe for the hard wood. This is very dense. I have some
cutoffs from a colleagues deck project where I helped to install the
decking.

Perhaps the ipe dust is adding to the abrasion of the mahogany.

I have not tried to plane ipe, but I have planed maple, which is not as
dense. Maple is not easy to get an even stroke. Depends on how long the
board is. I expect ipe is even harder to plane by hand.

I agree with the suggestion to try scraping. Less dust and can be a
smoother result.

Dave Paine.

"layman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> hi, my laminated woodworking project has epai and African mahogany
> strips in it. kind of like a butcherboard. No matter how straight a
> backing board I use. (I've even tried marble and tile) the softer wood
> sands first and I have "dents" where the harder wood is proud. I don't
> have access to a thickness sander. Any tips? Thank you.


You’ve reached the end of replies