Type of Wood - Mudroom Assistance

[email protected] wrote:
> Hello,
>
> I am looking at building a pretty simple cabinet and bench for our mud
> room. I am pretty new at this but have been using Oak for other
> things in my house and would like to change it up a little bit. The
> mudroom area is a kind of dark so I was looking at doing a lighter
> stain so it didn't make it any darker in there.
>
[snip]
Some years ago in my flatlander days, a fellow gave me his redwood deck
(he was putting in a new one). I have built a fair amount of deck or
mudroom furniture from it. There was some spalting which is now front
and center. Joinery is M&T. Finish is gloss Polycrylic, the first coat
being diluted by half. A bit of a rubdown after coat #4 to cut down on
the shine a bit. Looks good, wears well.
YMMV and mahalo,
jo4hn

Well, 9 times out of 10 my response to any question about what wood to
use is White Oak. The other 1 out of 10 I'll say Cherry.

WO is a good choice for wet environments. Sturdy. Looks good beat up.
You can just add a varnish and get a creamy yellowish color or stain
it to varying darkness'. If you use quartersawn, you get the addition
of some nice grain pattern\figure. Generally available and not
outlandishly expensive.

Look at http://www.taunton.com/finewoodworking/pages/fw_readshow_180.asp
at the cabinet at the bottom of the page for a good idea of a mid
range color. This has been slightly darkened.

As always with any oak, even if you are goig with a natural color it
is best to put a dark stain over a seal coat so you darken the grain
line patterns. Just apply shellac, then (after it dries of course)
wipe on a dark walnut gel stain and immediatly wipe it off. This will
leave the grain lines darkened. If you want an antiqued look, just
wipe less of it off in the corners, crevices, etc. You can really make
it look old by doing this and it is very easy to control if you keep
it wet while you decide how much to wipe off.

One trick I use to add a faux old look is to aggressively sand out
areas where there would have been natural wear, like edges of doors
near the handle, table corners, etc. Then when applying the darkening
layer, wipe it very clear at the wear areas to look as if some color
has been worn away too.


On Mar 12, 6:42=A0am, "[email protected]" <[email protected]> wrote:
> Hello,
>
> I am looking at building a pretty simple cabinet and bench for our mud
> room. =A0I am pretty new at this but have been using Oak for other
> things in my house and would like to change it up a little bit. =A0The
> mudroom area is a kind of dark so I was looking at doing a lighter
> stain so it didn't make it any darker in there.
>
> What type of wood would people use for this project and would also
> look good with an oak baseboard and raised panel doors that are
> already present? =A0I was thinking pine or aspen since they seem pretty
> reasonable? =A0Both pretty soft, but I am thinking about trying to go
> with a used look for the wood with the nail holes, etc.
>
> The area I am looking at putting this in is 42 inches deep by 36 wide
> by 8 feet tall. =A0A very strange deep area. =A0I was thinking on making
> the sitting bench nearly as deep as this spot and then stacking 2
> drawers side by side running the width of the area but make them only
> around 24 inches deep. =A0I would then add two tall cabinets that sit on
> top of the drawers and run nearly to the ceiling making them the same
> depth as the drawers. =A0This configuration seems a little strange, but
> I can't think of a better way to utilize this area. =A0Any ideas or
> pictures of things maybe you have done that could help?
>
> Thanks for the assistance.