TT

"Tim Taylor"

30/03/2006 5:44 PM

Planer knife sharpening

Has anyone ever used anything like this to sharpen your jointer or planer
knives? Or has anyone ever dealt with these people? What does the majority
do when your knives become dull? 30 bucks a set, versus 10 for one of these
gizmo's???



This topic has 12 replies

Mm

Markem

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 12:53 PM

On Thu, 30 Mar 2006 18:08:04 GMT, "Tim Taylor" <[email protected]>
wrote:

>I am so sorry!! I forgot to paste the link! Here it is:

I have one of those it is for honing the planer blades not sharpening.

Mark
(sixoneeight) = 618

tt

"tom"

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 9:58 AM

Used anything like what? Need more info, but I take mine to my local
sharpening service. They're responsive to my needs, and cost is
reasonable, and then I hone 'em up myself. Tom

Jj

"Josh"

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 10:42 AM

My father, who hates gimmicky "tools", got one as a gift a couple years
ago. He was just telling me the other day that it actually works
really well. He manages to hone the dulled edge on his knives three of
four times before finally having to take them out of the jointer and
get them sharpened. You can't keep sharpening forever with one of
these things, but it really adds a lot of life to the knives as long as
they're not too dull or notched up. He said it's really nice not to
have to take them out of the machine, since re-aligning them is
somewhat of a pain. I'm definitely thinking about getting one myself.

Josh



Tim Taylor wrote:
> Has anyone ever used anything like this to sharpen your jointer or planer
> knives? Or has anyone ever dealt with these people? What does the majority
> do when your knives become dull? 30 bucks a set, versus 10 for one of these
> gizmo's???

Bb

"BT98"

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 1:13 PM

I sent my Delta Thickness planer blades out for sharpening and when
they came back they did not want to feed the stock through the planer.
I talked to the tech center and they said the blades were not to be
resharpened. I replaced the feed roller and that did not help until I
replaced the blade with a new blade and then it would feed the stock
through the planer. I guess the honeing may help but grinding did not
work.

GG

"George"

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 2:28 PM


"Tim Taylor" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:88VWf.68176$oL.16528@attbi_s71...
>I am so sorry!! I forgot to paste the link! Here it is:
>
> http://www.constantines.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=656
>
> "tom" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
>> Used anything like what? Need more info, but I take mine to my local
>> sharpening service. They're responsive to my needs, and cost is
>> reasonable, and then I hone 'em up myself. Tom

Love my Makita water stone. I have two sets of blades, remove, the
offenders, ditto the jointer or planer, whichever is not offending, and have
an hour at the wheel. Usually do the plane irons then, too. This works
less like the stone than a "steel" for carving knives.

Br

Ba r r y

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

31/03/2006 11:55 AM

On Thu, 30 Mar 2006 20:33:28 GMT, "Tim Taylor" <[email protected]>
wrote:

>Woodcraft does it huh??? I guess I am looking in the wrong places then.
>That's just another good excuse to head to that side of town! Thanks Barry.

Mine does, but remember that Woodcraft stores are franchises. Most
of the time, tool stores send sharpening out with an "in this Tuesday,
back next Tuesday" type of deal.

If they don't do it, ask the manager for local recommendations.

SOMEONE will sharpen your blades! <G>

TT

"Tim Taylor"

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 6:08 PM

I am so sorry!! I forgot to paste the link! Here it is:

http://www.constantines.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=656

"tom" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Used anything like what? Need more info, but I take mine to my local
> sharpening service. They're responsive to my needs, and cost is
> reasonable, and then I hone 'em up myself. Tom
>

BA

B A R R Y

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 6:52 PM

Josh wrote:
> My father, who hates gimmicky "tools", got one as a gift a couple years
> ago. He was just telling me the other day that it actually works
> really well.

The secret is to remember it's a hone, not a sharpener.

If you use the hone early and often, the hone will work great. Once the
knives head toward dullsville, a hone isn't aggressive enough to do much
good, and a real sharpening is required.

It's kind of like touching up the bench chisels on 4000 and/or 8000 grit
stones during use.

TT

"Tim Taylor"

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 7:21 PM

Ok, gotcha! It's just for honing. I guess if I would have read a little
harder I would have figured that out my self. So it wouldn't do a couple
sets I got any good, cause they past dullsville about 300 miles back up the
road! Thanks guys. Guess it's off to get another new set until I can find
somebody around here that would do such a small job. That's 4 answers I got
when calling some places to see if they could sharpen them. "That's not
enough to warrant us even doing a job like that" or "just three sets of
blades? It would cost you more for us to sharpen them than it would for you
to buy a new set". Just answers like that.

"B A R R Y" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Josh wrote:
>> My father, who hates gimmicky "tools", got one as a gift a couple years
>> ago. He was just telling me the other day that it actually works
>> really well.
>
> The secret is to remember it's a hone, not a sharpener.
>
> If you use the hone early and often, the hone will work great. Once the
> knives head toward dullsville, a hone isn't aggressive enough to do much
> good, and a real sharpening is required.
>
> It's kind of like touching up the bench chisels on 4000 and/or 8000 grit
> stones during use.

TT

"Tim Taylor"

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 10:09 PM

Well, I was kinda, sorta wondering that myself. I know on one set I used, I
abused the crap out them. I was just planing down some old painted stair
treads, but about half way through it got hard for it to feed. By the time I
was done, I just about had to tie a rope on the ends and pull them through
with my truck. I know, that aint good on the equipment, but I had to do it.

"BT98" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>I sent my Delta Thickness planer blades out for sharpening and when
> they came back they did not want to feed the stock through the planer.
> I talked to the tech center and they said the blades were not to be
> resharpened. I replaced the feed roller and that did not help until I
> replaced the blade with a new blade and then it would feed the stock
> through the planer. I guess the honeing may help but grinding did not
> work.
>

BA

B A R R Y

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 7:34 PM

Tim Taylor wrote:
> "That's not
> enough to warrant us even doing a job like that" or "just three sets of
> blades? It would cost you more for us to sharpen them than it would for you
> to buy a new set".

My blades come back from sharpening trips much sharper than new blades.
This is precisely why I resharpen my 8" and 12" blades, as well as the
6" blades from my old jointer.

In my area, all of the local tool stores, like Woodcraft, Coastal.
etc... will send my blades out for sharpening, even if it's ONE blade.

You could also deal by mail with places like this:
<http://www.ballewtools.com/services.htm>
<http://www.ctsaw.com/aboutus.html>

Sharpening shops often work in batches, you're simply calling the wrong
places. Ask your local tool dealers.

TT

"Tim Taylor"

in reply to "Tim Taylor" on 30/03/2006 5:44 PM

30/03/2006 8:33 PM

Woodcraft does it huh??? I guess I am looking in the wrong places then.
That's just another good excuse to head to that side of town! Thanks Barry.

"B A R R Y" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Tim Taylor wrote:
>> "That's not enough to warrant us even doing a job like that" or "just
>> three sets of blades? It would cost you more for us to sharpen them than
>> it would for you to buy a new set".
>
> My blades come back from sharpening trips much sharper than new blades.
> This is precisely why I resharpen my 8" and 12" blades, as well as the 6"
> blades from my old jointer.
>
> In my area, all of the local tool stores, like Woodcraft, Coastal. etc...
> will send my blades out for sharpening, even if it's ONE blade.
>
> You could also deal by mail with places like this:
> <http://www.ballewtools.com/services.htm>
> <http://www.ctsaw.com/aboutus.html>
>
> Sharpening shops often work in batches, you're simply calling the wrong
> places. Ask your local tool dealers.


You’ve reached the end of replies