I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a chair
which I posted for view in the following link....
http://www.flickr.com/photos/18223943@N06/sets/72157628932677113/
As you can see, there are several repairs needed. The two cross braces under
the chair which are completely split and the main back support brace where
it attaches through the seat.
I can only think of two options available for the lower cross braces. Option
1) Repair with a good bonding agent, sand, wood fill if needed, sand and
finish or something along those lines. Option 2) make a new one with a
lathe, which I don't have, but have considered purchasing and use this
opportunity to start practicing.
The main back support brace is something I'm not sure how to approach
without needing to make another and bending, which I have no experience in
doing. As you can see where the screw is sticking out, the smaller
end/nipple is no longer there to be supported in the hole which is where I'm
stumped on how to approach.
The chair has been in my wife's family for years and I would really like to
help them keep it with good repairs.
Thank you
>
> The chair has been in my wife's family for years and I would really like to
> help them keep it with good repairs.
>
> Thank you
Wow someone has really inflicted some violence on this chair.
Basic principles.
Careful dissasembly as needed.
Use dowels and system 3 T88 epoxy. At each broken joint drill holes
into either side use a dowel to rejoin. Epoxy can be used to fill some
gaps. Wood putty can do the rest later. For places like the seat,
first epoxy in a new plug. Then drill in a dowel to the seat and post.
If they don't care too much about original finish, scuff the whole
thing, paint with black milk paint. Then sand lots of edges to show
through to under coat and to wood in some places. Then over coat with
shellac or satin wiping poly. Then wax and buff.
Justin Time wrote:
> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a chair
> which I posted for view in the following link....
> http://www.flickr.com/photos/18223943@N06/sets/72157628932677113/
>
> As you can see, there are several repairs needed. The two cross braces
> under the chair which are completely split and the main back support brace
> where it attaches through the seat.
>
> I can only think of two options available for the lower cross braces.
> Option 1) Repair with a good bonding agent, sand, wood fill if needed,
> sand and finish or something along those lines. Option 2) make a new one
> with a lathe, which I don't have, but have considered purchasing and use
> this opportunity to start practicing.
You could to Option 2, but only if you 1)have the patience of Job and/or
2)are willing to accept something less than "sterling." This being a
herloom piece, I don't think this is an option. Reparing the stretchers is
really very straight forward, especially with a high quality glue (such as
Titebond II)
>
> The main back support brace is something I'm not sure how to approach
> without needing to make another and bending, which I have no experience in
> doing. As you can see where the screw is sticking out, the smaller
> end/nipple is no longer there to be supported in the hole which is where
> I'm stumped on how to approach.
There are multiple problems here. Someone, (Who, you should never try to
find out as you will never look at them the same way again) tried to fix a
loose through tenon with a sheet metal screw. This person was definitely
NOT a woodworker. Here is what I would do:
Since the back is now loose from the seat, you have a "leg up" on the
project, as you do not have to remove it. Have a friend turn a piece to fit
the through hole in the seat and leave the top square, as DadOH suggested.,
But instead of a half lap joint, I would use a bridle joint, with the joint
running across rather than toward the front, that way you get support from
the joint rather than the glue having to hold all the weight of the person
leaning against the back. I would also put a "kerf cut" on the tenon and
drive a wedge up into it to secure it firmly in place. If you have a ream,
you could taper the hole a bit to the bottom to give the wedge more room to
work (that would also remove the old glue in the hole and give you a firmer
surface to glue to).
Also, when you put the back together, make sure you clean all the glue off
the mating surfaces and use a glue that has extremely good gap fill
qualities. Because when you remove the glue, you are going to loosen the
spindles in the holes. If those joints ever start to flex, the back will be
loose again.
Bottom line, it is not going to be an extremely difficult project, but you
will want to take your time and do your research before you make any cuts.
>
> The chair has been in my wife's family for years and I would really like
> to help them keep it with good repairs.
I love this line, its what seperates you from the "Individual" who put the
sheet metal screws in the tenons.
All the best.
Deb
On 1/20/2012 4:21 PM, Justin Time wrote:
> "Kris K. Kaput0"<[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
>>
>>
>> "Justin Time" wrote in message news:[email protected]...
>>
>>
>>> "Swingman"<[email protected]> wrote in message
>>> news:[email protected]...
>>> On 1/19/2012 8:21 PM, Justin Time wrote:
>>>>
>>>>>>> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a
>>>>>>> chair
>>>>
>>>>> Asking for differing approaches/suggestions doesn't hinder my ability
>>>>> to
>>>>> accomplish those suggestions. I simply don't always think of varying
>>>>> methods
>>>>> to resolve an issue. Therefore, I can assure you, from experience, I am
>>>>> very
>>>>> confident in my abilities to comprehend and apply solutions within many
>>>>> categories of life's projects. I have a vast resume' of successful
>>>>> repairs
>>>>> within my past and with many, I had basic ideas how to approach but
>>>>> better
>>>>> suggestions were made or I simply dived into the project and learned as
>>>>> I
>>>>> went.
>>>>
>>>> With all the "successful repairs within your past", and despite the fact
>>>> that you ask for help, in a newsgroup where you can't tell an expert
>>>> from a troll, we'll definitely be waiting to hear back on your own "vast
>>>> resume' of solutions for this chair.
>>>>
>>> I'll be more than happy to post photos when the task is complete.
>>>
>>>
>>
>> Try to stay out of bar fights next time!
>>
> Easy to do except when someone gets their panties in a bind because they
> believe another is inferior since they asked questions.
Can't help with your inferiority issues, Bubba ... you're gonna have to
deal with them yourself.
That said, you got what you asked for, advice on how to approach fixing
your chair, and sound advice at that, whether you like the advice or not.
And that advice still stands ... get an expert at chair repair to give
you a bid before trying to fix something yourself that, if you were
really the expert you have subsequently made yourself out to be, there
would have been no need to ask in the first place.
If you're going to argue/quibble about the advice you get around here,
you'll soon find yourself being told to fuck off.
AAMOF, fuck off ...
--
www.eWoodShop.com
Last update: 4/15/2010
KarlCaillouet@ (the obvious)
http://gplus.to/eWoodShop
On 1/19/2012 8:21 PM, Justin Time wrote:
>>> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a
>>> chair
> Asking for differing approaches/suggestions doesn't hinder my ability to
> accomplish those suggestions. I simply don't always think of varying methods
> to resolve an issue. Therefore, I can assure you, from experience, I am very
> confident in my abilities to comprehend and apply solutions within many
> categories of life's projects. I have a vast resume' of successful repairs
> within my past and with many, I had basic ideas how to approach but better
> suggestions were made or I simply dived into the project and learned as I
> went.
With all the "successful repairs within your past", and despite the fact
that you ask for help, in a newsgroup where you can't tell an expert
from a troll, we'll definitely be waiting to hear back on your own "vast
resume' of solutions for this chair.
--
www.eWoodShop.com
Last update: 4/15/2010
KarlCaillouet@ (the obvious)
http://gplus.to/eWoodShop
On Jan 19, 9:40=A0am, "SonomaProducts.com" <[email protected]> wrote:
> > The chair has been in my wife's family for years and I would really lik=
e to
> > help them keep it with good repairs.
>
> > Thank you
>
> NOTE: Just dissamble as needed, not the whole chair if possible.
Hopefully original (Long) post will show up to which this was a follow-
up note. Or I will post again later.
On Jan 19, 9:39=A0am, "SonomaProducts.com" <[email protected]> wrote:
> > The chair has been in my wife's family for years and I would really lik=
e to
> > help them keep it with good repairs.
>
> > Thank you
>
> Wow someone has really inflicted some violence on this chair.
>
> Basic principles.
>
> Careful dissasembly as needed.
>
> Use dowels and system 3 T88 epoxy. At each broken joint drill holes
> into either side use a dowel to rejoin. Epoxy can be used to fill some
> gaps. Wood putty can do the rest later. For places like the seat,
> first epoxy in a new plug. Then drill in a dowel to the seat and post.
>
> If they don't care too much about original finish, scuff the whole
> thing, paint with black milk paint. Then sand lots of edges to show
> through to under coat and to wood in some places. Then over coat with
> shellac or satin wiping poly. Then wax and buff.
Glue in the dowels.
Justin Time wrote:
> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a
> chair which I posted for view in the following link....
> http://www.flickr.com/photos/18223943@N06/sets/72157628932677113/
>
> As you can see, there are several repairs needed. The two cross
> braces under the chair which are completely split and the main back
> support brace where it attaches through the seat.
>
> I can only think of two options available for the lower cross braces.
> Option 1) Repair with a good bonding agent, sand, wood fill if
> needed, sand and finish or something along those lines. Option 2)
> make a new one with a lathe, which I don't have, but have considered
> purchasing and use this opportunity to start practicing.
Option 1 should work fine. Use epoxy and thicken the epoxy with something
like Cab-o-Sil or micro-balloons. Or even fine wood dust. You need to
thicken the epoxy to the point of being about like Vaseline and the reason
is to fill areas that are an imperfect match.
_____________________
> The main back support brace is something I'm not sure how to approach
> without needing to make another and bending, which I have no
> experience in doing. As you can see where the screw is sticking out,
> the smaller end/nipple is no longer there to be supported in the hole
> which is where I'm stumped on how to approach.
No need to make a new one, repair the old.
1. Drill/clean out the hole where the support was.
2. Make a short new piece to fit the hole. Make part of it round for the
hole but leave a couple of additional inches square. Shape the square part
to match the existing square part and cut a vertical half lap in it.
3.Dry fit the new part in the hole and use it to determine where to cut a
matching half lap in the existing piece.
4. Glue the new piece into the hole and glue the half laps together
- ALTERNATIVELY -
1. Clean out the hole and glue in a new piece, cutting it flush with the
top.
2. Position the broken brace and - from the bottom - drill into it through
the new piece. Make the hole about 1/2 the diameter of the new piece and
drill into the broken piece about an inch.
3. Glue in an appropriately sized dowel.
_____________________________
Note: Spindles such as those in your chair get a lot of pressure. The glue
in the holes gets old. The combination of the two is what gets them loose
or broken. Screws going lengthwise into the spindle don't do much good
because they are going into the end grain of the spindle. A better way to
fasten them is to use a horizontal pin drilling through them from the back
of the seat. That pin can be a piece of brass rod - 1/8" is plenty - a wood
dowel or even a nail.
--
dadiOH
____________________________
dadiOH's dandies v3.06...
...a help file of info about MP3s, recording from
LP/cassette and tips & tricks on this and that.
Get it at http://mysite.verizon.net/xico
"Swingman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> On 1/18/2012 6:33 PM, Justin Time wrote:
>> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a
>> chair
>> which I posted for view in the following link....
>> http://www.flickr.com/photos/18223943@N06/sets/72157628932677113/
>
>> The chair has been in my wife's family for years and I would really like
>> to
>> help them keep it with good repairs.
>
> Before you start, understand the fact that since you had to ask means you
> do not have the skills to do the job properly, and I see nothing in the
> advice thus far that will magically overcome that.
>
> AAMOF, looking back over the thread everything I see as a fix is, IMO,
> either going to get you in trouble and/or put you back in worse shape the
> next time there is a problem, and probably sooner rather than later.
>
> Is the chair valuable enough to the family that you don't want to practice
> on it?
>
> If the answer is "Yes", take it to someone who knows what they are doing
> with this particular type of chair and have them give you an estimate
> before you begin your chair restoration career with this beautiful chair.
>
> There is nothing that I see that should be extraordinarily expensive to
> fix for someone with the expertise, in fact, almost all the fixes are very
> simple and straight forward it you have the experience and tools.
>
> If the answer is "No", have at it, but think as hard as you can about
> coming up with fixes that use nothing but hide glue if you want the chair
> to be fixable again in the future.
Asking for differing approaches/suggestions doesn't hinder my ability to
accomplish those suggestions. I simply don't always think of varying methods
to resolve an issue. Therefore, I can assure you, from experience, I am very
confident in my abilities to comprehend and apply solutions within many
categories of life's projects. I have a vast resume' of successful repairs
within my past and with many, I had basic ideas how to approach but better
suggestions were made or I simply dived into the project and learned as I
went. But thanks for the concern.
"Swingman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> On 1/19/2012 8:21 PM, Justin Time wrote:
>
>>>> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a
>>>> chair
>
>> Asking for differing approaches/suggestions doesn't hinder my ability to
>> accomplish those suggestions. I simply don't always think of varying
>> methods
>> to resolve an issue. Therefore, I can assure you, from experience, I am
>> very
>> confident in my abilities to comprehend and apply solutions within many
>> categories of life's projects. I have a vast resume' of successful
>> repairs
>> within my past and with many, I had basic ideas how to approach but
>> better
>> suggestions were made or I simply dived into the project and learned as I
>> went.
>
> With all the "successful repairs within your past", and despite the fact
> that you ask for help, in a newsgroup where you can't tell an expert from
> a troll, we'll definitely be waiting to hear back on your own "vast
> resume' of solutions for this chair.
>
I'll be more than happy to post photos when the task is complete.
"Justin Time" wrote in message news:[email protected]...
> "Swingman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
> On 1/19/2012 8:21 PM, Justin Time wrote:
>>
>>>>> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a
>>>>> chair
>>
>>> Asking for differing approaches/suggestions doesn't hinder my ability to
>>> accomplish those suggestions. I simply don't always think of varying
>>> methods
>>> to resolve an issue. Therefore, I can assure you, from experience, I am
>>> very
>>> confident in my abilities to comprehend and apply solutions within many
>>> categories of life's projects. I have a vast resume' of successful
>>> repairs
>>> within my past and with many, I had basic ideas how to approach but
>>> better
>>> suggestions were made or I simply dived into the project and learned as
>>> I
>>> went.
>>
>> With all the "successful repairs within your past", and despite the fact
>> that you ask for help, in a newsgroup where you can't tell an expert from
>> a troll, we'll definitely be waiting to hear back on your own "vast
>> resume' of solutions for this chair.
>>
> I'll be more than happy to post photos when the task is complete.
>
>
Try to stay out of bar fights next time!
--
KKK
"Kris K. Kaput0" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>
>
> "Justin Time" wrote in message news:[email protected]...
>
>
>> "Swingman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
>> news:[email protected]...
>> On 1/19/2012 8:21 PM, Justin Time wrote:
>>>
>>>>>> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a
>>>>>> chair
>>>
>>>> Asking for differing approaches/suggestions doesn't hinder my ability
>>>> to
>>>> accomplish those suggestions. I simply don't always think of varying
>>>> methods
>>>> to resolve an issue. Therefore, I can assure you, from experience, I am
>>>> very
>>>> confident in my abilities to comprehend and apply solutions within many
>>>> categories of life's projects. I have a vast resume' of successful
>>>> repairs
>>>> within my past and with many, I had basic ideas how to approach but
>>>> better
>>>> suggestions were made or I simply dived into the project and learned as
>>>> I
>>>> went.
>>>
>>> With all the "successful repairs within your past", and despite the fact
>>> that you ask for help, in a newsgroup where you can't tell an expert
>>> from a troll, we'll definitely be waiting to hear back on your own "vast
>>> resume' of solutions for this chair.
>>>
>> I'll be more than happy to post photos when the task is complete.
>>
>>
>
> Try to stay out of bar fights next time!
>
Easy to do except when someone gets their panties in a bind because they
believe another is inferior since they asked questions.
"Swingman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>
> Can't help with your inferiority issues, Bubba ... you're gonna have to
> deal with them yourself.
>
> That said, you got what you asked for, advice on how to approach fixing
> your chair, and sound advice at that, whether you like the advice or not.
>
> And that advice still stands ... get an expert at chair repair to give you
> a bid before trying to fix something yourself that, if you were really the
> expert you have subsequently made yourself out to be, there would have
> been no need to ask in the first place.
>
> If you're going to argue/quibble about the advice you get around here,
> you'll soon find yourself being told to fuck off.
>
> AAMOF, fuck off ...
>
Your perceptive chest thumping is stroking your ego just a tad too much, but
some require aloofness.
Regardless, please show me where I said I was an expert and please show me
where I complained about the advice? The advice was sound from everyone but
yourself due to their achievement of staying on topic to the question and
that doesn't warrant complaint.
The obvious conclusion is you felt the need of superiority by suggesting an
inferior ability based on asking suggestions for a project. You obviously
couldn't handle the reply I provided indicating my confidence and instead of
simply letting go, you further stroked your ego with greater attempts of
insults and yet, you have the audacity to label another as inferior...LMAO!
As for that inferior issues, view mirror. As for being told to fuck
off......get in line. It won't be the first nor last.
Your need to feel superior will result in having the last say. I'm done and
thank all those who provided great advice regarding the chair.
On 1/18/2012 6:33 PM, Justin Time wrote:
> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a chair
> which I posted for view in the following link....
> http://www.flickr.com/photos/18223943@N06/sets/72157628932677113/
> The chair has been in my wife's family for years and I would really like to
> help them keep it with good repairs.
Before you start, understand the fact that since you had to ask means
you do not have the skills to do the job properly, and I see nothing in
the advice thus far that will magically overcome that.
AAMOF, looking back over the thread everything I see as a fix is, IMO,
either going to get you in trouble and/or put you back in worse shape
the next time there is a problem, and probably sooner rather than later.
Is the chair valuable enough to the family that you don't want to
practice on it?
If the answer is "Yes", take it to someone who knows what they are doing
with this particular type of chair and have them give you an estimate
before you begin your chair restoration career with this beautiful chair.
There is nothing that I see that should be extraordinarily expensive to
fix for someone with the expertise, in fact, almost all the fixes are
very simple and straight forward it you have the experience and tools.
If the answer is "No", have at it, but think as hard as you can about
coming up with fixes that use nothing but hide glue if you want the
chair to be fixable again in the future.
--
www.eWoodShop.com
Last update: 4/15/2010
KarlCaillouet@ (the obvious)
http://gplus.to/eWoodShop
Swingman wrote:
> On 1/18/2012 6:33 PM, Justin Time wrote:
>> I'm wondering if the experts can help me with suggestion to repair a
>> chair which I posted for view in the following link....
>> http://www.flickr.com/photos/18223943@N06/sets/72157628932677113/
>
>> The chair has been in my wife's family for years and I would really like
>> to help them keep it with good repairs.
>
> Before you start, understand the fact that since you had to ask means
> you do not have the skills to do the job properly, and I see nothing in
> the advice thus far that will magically overcome that.
>
> AAMOF, looking back over the thread everything I see as a fix is, IMO,
> either going to get you in trouble and/or put you back in worse shape
> the next time there is a problem, and probably sooner rather than later.
>
> Is the chair valuable enough to the family that you don't want to
> practice on it?
>
> If the answer is "Yes", take it to someone who knows what they are doing
> with this particular type of chair and have them give you an estimate
> before you begin your chair restoration career with this beautiful chair.
>
> There is nothing that I see that should be extraordinarily expensive to
> fix for someone with the expertise, in fact, almost all the fixes are
> very simple and straight forward it you have the experience and tools.
>
> If the answer is "No", have at it, but think as hard as you can about
> coming up with fixes that use nothing but hide glue if you want the
> chair to be fixable again in the future.
>
>
I thought about that (i.e., lack of skill) but with all the other stuff I
was tossing his way, thought it might be seen as condesension. But you are
absolutely right. If Justing does not feel his skills are up to the task,
get someone else to do it. Better than than a muffed job.
Deb