DJ

"D. J. Dorn"

06/01/2005 5:15 PM

New Porter Cable Dovetail Jig

I've been intriqued by this new jig and looked one over and really liked
what I saw. Since someone was already interested in my old 4112, I sold it
and bought the 4212 looking forward to through and sliding dovetails.

Got the box home and really like the bulk of it but there are some things I
should clear up of which I was mistaken in my assumptions. The through
dovetail template is fixed, not adjustable. However the worst thing and the
thing that really ticks me off is it calls for a 17/32" 7 degree dovetail
bit. While one came with it, it looks like it's propretary and I'm stuck
with PC bits - when they finally distribute them.

The half blind template is based a 3/4" guide bushing as opposed to the 5/8"
of the 4112. I tried a 1/2" x 1/2" 8 degree and my old 14 degree 1/2 bit.
Neither worked. I wont take it back because I'd just have to wind up buying
another 4112 but I sure hope someone starts producing 17/32 7 degree bits so
I'm not stuck having to buy PC bits. Lost a little respect for them on this
one - I think the Omnijig will survive afterall Leon - good.

Don


This topic has 8 replies

DJ

"D. J. Dorn"

in reply to "D. J. Dorn" on 06/01/2005 5:15 PM

07/01/2005 7:00 AM

Thanks Leon, I'll look into that. I see that MLCS has a 9/16" 7 degree
which is just a tad wider than the PC bit but angle is the same - I tend to
agree with you providing the angles are the same - we'll see.

Don

"Leon" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>
> "D. J. Dorn" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
>
>> Got the box home and really like the bulk of it but there are some things
>> I should clear up of which I was mistaken in my assumptions. The through
>> dovetail template is fixed, not adjustable. However the worst thing and
>> the thing that really ticks me off is it calls for a 17/32" 7 degree
>> dovetail bit. While one came with it, it looks like it's propretary and
>> I'm stuck with PC bits - when they finally distribute them.
>
>
> I am not familiar with your new jig but I have the Leigh jig. Leigh sells
> several DT bits for through DT's that are all the same angle. They do
> differ in cutting depth and naturally cut wider as they cut deeper. The
> different length DT bits are for different thickness boards and for
> different appearances. Therefore the length and diameter "may not" be
> critical depending on the thickness of wood you are using with you new
> jig.. That said, Infinity sells several 7 degree DT bits.
>
> http://www.infinitytools.com/products.asp?dept=1017
>

DJ

"D. J. Dorn"

in reply to "D. J. Dorn" on 06/01/2005 5:15 PM

07/01/2005 10:11 AM

Depth of the cut in't the issue but I tried the old tried and true 14 degree
1/2" bit. What happened was that if you use the 3/4" collar which is
necessary for the template, the pins come out way to large. If you use that
bit with the old 5/8" collar, the tails are much too large for the pins.
I'm going to find a compriable bit if it kills me.

Don

<[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>
> D. J. Dorn wrote:
>> I've been intriqued by this new jig and looked one over and really
> liked
>> what I saw. Since someone was already interested in my old 4112, I
> sold it
>> and bought the 4212 looking forward to through and sliding dovetails.
>
>
>> Got the box home and really like the bulk of it but there are some
> things I
>> should clear up of which I was mistaken in my assumptions. The
> through
>> dovetail template is fixed, not adjustable. However the worst thing
> and the
>> thing that really ticks me off is it calls for a 17/32" 7 degree
> dovetail
>> bit. While one came with it, it looks like it's propretary and I'm
> stuck
>> with PC bits - when they finally distribute them.
>
> i don't know the jig, but for half-blind I would think you can use any
> bit since you only use the dovetail bit to cut both pin and tail
> pieces. Fit is determined by the depth of the bit.
>

ll

in reply to "D. J. Dorn" on 06/01/2005 5:15 PM

07/01/2005 5:06 AM

> I am not familiar with your new jig but I have the Leigh jig. Leigh
sells
> several DT bits for through DT's that are all the same angle. They
do
> differ in cutting depth and naturally cut wider as they cut deeper.
The
> different length DT bits are for different thickness boards and for
> different appearances. Therefore the length and diameter "may not"
be
> critical depending on the thickness of wood you are using with you
new jig..
> That said, Infinity sells several 7 degree DT bits.
>
> http://www.infinitytools.com/products.asp?dept=1017

I bought the set from Lee Valley for the Leigh jig, and there ARE
different angles to a couple of the bits.

ll

in reply to "D. J. Dorn" on 06/01/2005 5:15 PM

07/01/2005 5:08 AM


D. J. Dorn wrote:
> I've been intriqued by this new jig and looked one over and really
liked
> what I saw. Since someone was already interested in my old 4112, I
sold it
> and bought the 4212 looking forward to through and sliding dovetails.


> Got the box home and really like the bulk of it but there are some
things I
> should clear up of which I was mistaken in my assumptions. The
through
> dovetail template is fixed, not adjustable. However the worst thing
and the
> thing that really ticks me off is it calls for a 17/32" 7 degree
dovetail
> bit. While one came with it, it looks like it's propretary and I'm
stuck
> with PC bits - when they finally distribute them.

i don't know the jig, but for half-blind I would think you can use any
bit since you only use the dovetail bit to cut both pin and tail
pieces. Fit is determined by the depth of the bit.

Lr

"Leon"

in reply to "D. J. Dorn" on 06/01/2005 5:15 PM

07/01/2005 4:17 AM


"D. J. Dorn" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...

> Got the box home and really like the bulk of it but there are some things
> I should clear up of which I was mistaken in my assumptions. The through
> dovetail template is fixed, not adjustable. However the worst thing and
> the thing that really ticks me off is it calls for a 17/32" 7 degree
> dovetail bit. While one came with it, it looks like it's propretary and
> I'm stuck with PC bits - when they finally distribute them.


I am not familiar with your new jig but I have the Leigh jig. Leigh sells
several DT bits for through DT's that are all the same angle. They do
differ in cutting depth and naturally cut wider as they cut deeper. The
different length DT bits are for different thickness boards and for
different appearances. Therefore the length and diameter "may not" be
critical depending on the thickness of wood you are using with you new jig..
That said, Infinity sells several 7 degree DT bits.

http://www.infinitytools.com/products.asp?dept=1017

tt

"toller"

in reply to "D. J. Dorn" on 06/01/2005 5:15 PM

06/01/2005 11:34 PM

Sorry about your misfortune, but having bought an omnijig last month...

tt

"toller"

in reply to "D. J. Dorn" on 06/01/2005 5:15 PM

07/01/2005 8:54 AM


"toller" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Sorry about your misfortune, but having bought an omnijig last month...
>
Interestingly, Amazon has moved the 7216 back up to $399.99. I got mine
last monty for $252; and go wrong at that price.

Lr

"Leon"

in reply to "D. J. Dorn" on 06/01/2005 5:15 PM

07/01/2005 4:23 PM


<[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>> http://www.infinitytools.com/products.asp?dept=1017
>
> I bought the set from Lee Valley for the Leigh jig, and there ARE
> different angles to a couple of the bits.
>

Thanks for clarifying Larry. Is your set for all DT's including Blind DT's?
If so that would explain the different angles in the set. IIRC the through
DT's all use the same angle bit. That angle compliments the angles on the
jig tail fingers. With the Blind DT set up the cuts all go straight in when
cutting both the tails and pins. When cutting through DT's the tails are
cut with the DT bit and the pins are cut with a straight bit that is guided
by the tail fingers that guide the bit at the same angle that the DT bit is
manufactured at. Clear as mud? LOL


You’ve reached the end of replies