Finally making the base for my bench, I have had a number of 4x6 or so
dunnage pieces that I had packed home thinking it was white oak, but
they sure don't look like the white oak board I have for a later
project:
http://www.webbyhome.com:8080/ia5/photos/bench/end_grain.jpg
for a 5.5 meg tiff:
http://alan.firebin.net/end_grain.tif
and the face side after the bandsaw
http://www.webbyhome.com:8080/ia5/photos/bench/20060101_bench_feet2.jpg
Frank Ketchum wrote:
> "arw01" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
> > Finally making the base for my bench, I have had a number of 4x6 or so
> > dunnage pieces that I had packed home thinking it was white oak, but
> > they sure don't look like the white oak board I have for a later
> > project:
> >
> > http://www.webbyhome.com:8080/ia5/photos/bench/end_grain.jpg
> >
> >
>
> Looks like oak. The open pores in the end grain suggest that it is red oak
> rather than white.
It may be live or willow oak. Live oak has an interlocking grain and
is difficult to split--a desirable trait for dunnage. Red oak splits
easily.
Some folks consider live oak to be red oak. Others divide oaks
into four groups, rather than two--red, white, live and willow, and
chestnut oak.
I suppose chestnut oak is another possibility.
--
FF
"arw01" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Finally making the base for my bench, I have had a number of 4x6 or so
> dunnage pieces that I had packed home thinking it was white oak, but
> they sure don't look like the white oak board I have for a later
> project:
>
> http://www.webbyhome.com:8080/ia5/photos/bench/end_grain.jpg
>
>
Looks like oak. The open pores in the end grain suggest that it is red oak
rather than white.
"Leon" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Absolutely, it is Oak.
>
>
Actually the end grain pics look like RED Oak while I would say possibly
White Oak on the face pictures.
On 20 Jan 2006 07:04:04 -0800, "arw01" <[email protected]>
wrote:
>they sure don't look like the white oak board I have for a later
>project:
Don't think it's white oak. Both red and white oaks have pores, but
white oak pores are blocked up.
Could be red oak (most likely) but it could also be chestnut or elm.
It's hard to tell from the end grain photo. If the rays are visible
then it's oak. These rays look a little skinny for oak though, but still
too visible for chestnut or elm.
I'd incline towards "some weird red oak". There are an awful lot of oaks
out there that aren't Q. alba or Q. rubra. They also hybridise easily,
so you can find local variants that just don't appear anywhere else.
Shoudl make a fine bench. Finishing is a it of a lottery with red oak,
some is great, some looks dull and ugly. Shouldn't be a problem for a
bench though.
Absolutely, it is Oak.
"arw01" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Finally making the base for my bench, I have had a number of 4x6 or so
> dunnage pieces that I had packed home thinking it was white oak, but
> they sure don't look like the white oak board I have for a later
> project:
>
> http://www.webbyhome.com:8080/ia5/photos/bench/end_grain.jpg
>
> for a 5.5 meg tiff:
>
> http://alan.firebin.net/end_grain.tif
>
> and the face side after the bandsaw
>
> http://www.webbyhome.com:8080/ia5/photos/bench/20060101_bench_feet2.jpg
>
Fri, Jan 20, 2006, 3:24pm (EST+5) [email protected] (Leon)
doth claimeth:
Absolutely, it is Oak.
Free wood is always popular wood.
JOAT
If you can't say anything nice about someone, you must be talking about
Hilary Clinton.