Ok, went into my shop last week, flicked on the overhead lights
and damn, two of my lights are out.
Changed the bulbs (T8s) and still nothing. I remembered that
one of the fixtures that's hidden behind the overhead door, so
I never see it, had a bad ballast. (I never replaced it because
the door hides the light - I blame the electrician for putting it
there, but
so it goes). So, I'm assuming that
I've got 3 lights out because of bad ballasts. I bought some
replacements via eBay on Monday, so I'm planning to swap them out
Friday. But ask, is this normal for those "garage light specials"
sold at local home centers? Anyone else have similar problems?
Or did I have a run of bad luck?
The lights were bought and installed about 7 years ago. They are NOT
used all the much. Not as much as other fluorescent fixtures in the
house.
MJ
On Wed, 25 Jul 2012 11:07:36 -0700, Mike M
<[email protected]> wrote:
>On Tue, 24 Jul 2012 11:03:23 -0700 (PDT), MJ <[email protected]>
>wrote:
>
>>Ok, went into my shop last week, flicked on the overhead lights
>>and damn, two of my lights are out.
>>
>>Changed the bulbs (T8s) and still nothing. I remembered that
>>one of the fixtures that's hidden behind the overhead door, so
>>I never see it, had a bad ballast. (I never replaced it because
>>the door hides the light - I blame the electrician for putting it
>>there, but
>>so it goes). So, I'm assuming that
>>I've got 3 lights out because of bad ballasts. I bought some
>>replacements via eBay on Monday, so I'm planning to swap them out
>>Friday. But ask, is this normal for those "garage light specials"
>>sold at local home centers? Anyone else have similar problems?
>>Or did I have a run of bad luck?
>>
>>The lights were bought and installed about 7 years ago. They are NOT
>>used all the much. Not as much as other fluorescent fixtures in the
>>house.
>>
>>MJ
>
>Your ahead to pay extra for a commercial grade of fixture. Ballasts
>will last longer and generally have a better output.
>
>Mike M
I too have had bad history with the fixtures from HD and Lowes. I
didn't buy the real cheapies, but the next grade up. I have 20+ of
them, 2 tube with reflectors, going on 3-4 years. Half of them at
least have failed, and there are two dark now.
I read online that there was supposedly a "bad batch" of ballasts but
a couple of the replacement fixtures I bought more recently have also
failed.
My big gripe is the fixture manufacturer doesn't typically warrant the
ballast. Dealing with the ballast manufacturer was an exercise in
frustration.
The other issue is knowing whether a fixture is commercial grade or
just more expensive. For example, looking at grainger or McMaster,
one of them sells Lithonia, the same brand I bought at the Borg. How
do I know it has a better grade of ballast? They are 2-4x the price
but that's not a reliable indicator.
I'm moving my shop to other side of basement and plan to put in new
fixtures. I will be really, really pissed if I pay $80-100+ for 4
tube wrap fixtures and they don't last any longer than the borg
variety at less than half the price.
Anyone bought Lithonia from Mc-Granger and can report?
Paul F.
> Anyone bought Lithonia from Mc-Granger and can report?
>
Paul,
I'd ask around at some electrical supply shops what they have.
No, not at the Borg or any similar place, there's got to
be an electrical supply center in your city or close to it.
What you probably want are the "factory" or what I would
call "the pro" lights. They would go into a commercial building.
I looked at those lights on-line and found them to be
in the range you're talking about. You might ask around
some places where you know people and ask them about
their lights. Chances are they only have to replace the lights
so often and not the ballasts.
MJ
[...snip...]
>But ask, is this normal for those "garage light specials"
>sold at local home centers? Anyone else have similar problems?
>Or did I have a run of bad luck?
>
[...snip...]
I did a new workshop/garage install about 10 years ago; I bought 4' T8
shop lights from Home Depot with electronic ballasts. All of the
ballasts failed within about 18 months.
I replaced the ballasts with some Internet name brand like GE or
similar and have had no problems since. I think I was in the $12 range
for the new ballasts, so it was cheaper than buying new fixtures.
On Saturday, July 28, 2012 4:42:20 PM UTC-7, MJ wrote:
> > Anyone bought Lithonia from Mc-Granger and can report?
>
> I'd ask around at some electrical supply shops what they have.
>
> No, not at the Borg or any similar place, there's got to
>
> be an electrical supply center in your city or close to it.
Bingo! The local supply center that sells to electricians is likely
to have more and more current info than we web denizens,
and you'll have a top-notch ballast the same day.
I've liked Motorola ballasts, but brands and models change too
fast for anyone but the pros to have any good handle on quality.
On Wed, 01 Aug 2012 19:10:47 -0700, Jim Weisgram
<[email protected]> wrote:
>
>[...snip...]
>>But ask, is this normal for those "garage light specials"
>>sold at local home centers? Anyone else have similar problems?
>>Or did I have a run of bad luck?
>>
>[...snip...]
>I did a new workshop/garage install about 10 years ago; I bought 4' T8
>shop lights from Home Depot with electronic ballasts. All of the
>ballasts failed within about 18 months.
>
>I replaced the ballasts with some Internet name brand like GE or
>similar and have had no problems since. I think I was in the $12 range
>for the new ballasts, so it was cheaper than buying new fixtures.
ISTM that it's cheaper to buy lower cost fixtures then replace ballasts with
decent ones as they fail. Buying a higher priced fixture doesn't necessarily
get a better ballast.
MJ wrote:
> Ok, went into my shop last week, flicked on the overhead lights
> and damn, two of my lights are out.
>
> Changed the bulbs (T8s) and still nothing. I remembered that
> one of the fixtures that's hidden behind the overhead door, so
> I never see it, had a bad ballast. (I never replaced it because
> the door hides the light - I blame the electrician for putting it
> there, but
> so it goes). So, I'm assuming that
> I've got 3 lights out because of bad ballasts. I bought some
> replacements via eBay on Monday, so I'm planning to swap them out
> Friday. But ask, is this normal for those "garage light specials"
> sold at local home centers? Anyone else have similar problems?
> Or did I have a run of bad luck?
>
> The lights were bought and installed about 7 years ago. They are NOT
> used all the much. Not as much as other fluorescent fixtures in the
> house.
Couple of thoughts - yes it is normal. One thing with florescents is to
make sure you have a good solid ground to each light. Very important.
After that - you get what you pay for. Some of the cheap electronic ballast
lights work for years. Some do not. You gets what you pay for. I don't
see anything abnormal from what you've described.
--
-Mike-
[email protected]
Mike M wrote:
>
> Your ahead to pay extra for a commercial grade of fixture. Ballasts
> will last longer and generally have a better output.
>
> Mike M
I generally agree with statements like yours Mike, but in the case of garage
lights, my experience has been different. I've got almost 20 of the big box
cheap shop lights in my garage (all of them zero degree lights), and my
failure rate over a period of greater than 10 years has been miniscule.
Some of them are from Lowes and some are from HD, so there is a mixed bag of
stuff out there. I use my lights daily, so it's not light they don't get
use. For the failure rates that I have seen, it was way better for me to go
with the cheap stuff than to go commercial.
--
-Mike-
[email protected]
On Tue, 24 Jul 2012 11:03:23 -0700 (PDT), MJ <[email protected]>
wrote:
>Ok, went into my shop last week, flicked on the overhead lights
>and damn, two of my lights are out.
>
>Changed the bulbs (T8s) and still nothing. I remembered that
>one of the fixtures that's hidden behind the overhead door, so
>I never see it, had a bad ballast. (I never replaced it because
>the door hides the light - I blame the electrician for putting it
>there, but
>so it goes). So, I'm assuming that
>I've got 3 lights out because of bad ballasts. I bought some
>replacements via eBay on Monday, so I'm planning to swap them out
>Friday. But ask, is this normal for those "garage light specials"
>sold at local home centers? Anyone else have similar problems?
>Or did I have a run of bad luck?
>
>The lights were bought and installed about 7 years ago. They are NOT
>used all the much. Not as much as other fluorescent fixtures in the
>house.
>
>MJ
Your ahead to pay extra for a commercial grade of fixture. Ballasts
will last longer and generally have a better output.
Mike M
On Tue, 24 Jul 2012 11:03:23 -0700, MJ wrote:
> But ask, is
> this normal for those "garage light specials" sold at local home
> centers? Anyone else have similar problems? Or did I have a run of bad
> luck?
That's normal for cheap shop lights. And it's usually cheaper to replace
the whole light than to buy a decent ballast.
--
Intelligence is an experiment that failed - G. B. Shaw
On 7/25/12 4:25 PM, Mike Marlow wrote:
> Mike M wrote:
>
>>
>> Your ahead to pay extra for a commercial grade of fixture. Ballasts
>> will last longer and generally have a better output.
>>
>> Mike M
>
> I generally agree with statements like yours Mike, but in the case of garage
> lights, my experience has been different. I've got almost 20 of the big box
> cheap shop lights in my garage (all of them zero degree lights), and my
> failure rate over a period of greater than 10 years has been miniscule.
> Some of them are from Lowes and some are from HD, so there is a mixed bag of
> stuff out there. I use my lights daily, so it's not light they don't get
> use. For the failure rates that I have seen, it was way better for me to go
> with the cheap stuff than to go commercial.
>
We must be buying the same lights. :-)
First batch didn't last 18 months. This batch is going on several years.
--
-MIKE-
"Playing is not something I do at night, it's my function in life"
--Elvin Jones (1927-2004)
--
http://mikedrums.com
[email protected]
---remove "DOT" ^^^^ to reply
On Wed, 25 Jul 2012 00:03:34 +0000 (UTC), Larry Blanchard
<[email protected]> wrote:
>On Tue, 24 Jul 2012 11:03:23 -0700, MJ wrote:
>
>> But ask, is
>> this normal for those "garage light specials" sold at local home
>> centers? Anyone else have similar problems? Or did I have a run of bad
>> luck?
>
>That's normal for cheap shop lights. And it's usually cheaper to replace
>the whole light than to buy a decent ballast.
But then you still have a cheap ballast.