Mm

MikeK

23/12/2004 9:31 PM

Porter Cable Omnijig

I'm thinking of getting a dovetail jig after the first of the year.
The PC Omnijig (16 inch) looks good. Any pros and cons from owners
would be appreciated.

Thanks,

Mike


This topic has 16 replies

tt

"toller"

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 9:31 PM

24/12/2004 4:42 AM

You have to tell us what you want to use it for! It is well suited for
somethings, and not so good for others.

Sa

"Steve"

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 9:31 PM

23/12/2004 11:56 PM


"MikeK" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 04:36:51 GMT, max <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>>I had a big one with all of the attachments. I made a lot of drawers with
>>the half blind dovetail template. Used the 1/4 inch finger joint a lot.
>>Had
>>the adjustable dovetail set and it worked fine. The biggest problem with
>>all
>>of these jigs on the market is the simpler the jig the easiest to learn.
>>The
>>Omni will do a great job but it takes time to learn.
>>max
>>
>
> Time to learn is no problem. I'll be retiring in June.
>
> Mike
>
Since that's the case, why not start now to learn to whack 'em out by hand?

By the time it might take to master the PC Omnijig you could be teaching the
rest of us how to to use Japanese pull saws to cut the little debils --
you'd save a small fortune and you could charge tuition to make up for the
SS losses sure to come :-/
--
Enjoy life and *do* well by it
-- it might well be the only chance you get :-)

Steve,
http://www.ApacheTrail.com/ww/

Mm

MikeK

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 9:31 PM

24/12/2004 5:20 PM

On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 05:42:38 GMT, "toller" <[email protected]> wrote:

>
>"MikeK" <[email protected]> wrote in message
>news:[email protected]...
>> On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 04:42:37 GMT, "toller" <[email protected]> wrote:
>>
>>>You have to tell us what you want to use it for! It is well suited for
>>>somethings, and not so good for others.
>>>
>>
>> Well, I would like to make different kinds of boxes and new kitchen
>> drawers with it to start. What is it not suited well for.
>>
>It would be great for new kitchen drawers. If comes into it's own making a
>lot of exactly the same standard half blind dovetails; like what your
>kitchen drawers will need. Though the 16" capacity will be wasted. Maybe a
>smaller, cheaper, jig will be okay for that also, but none have the
>reassuring mass of an omnijig. (The 24" weighs 60 pounds; I don't know about
>the 16".)
>
>It is not so good with creative variable stuff. Some of the other, more
>complicated, jigs do that better.
>

PC has, or will have soon, a new model 4212 12" deluxe Jig. The PC
site makes it sound good. I'll wait till I can actually look at the
12" deluxe and the 16" Omnijig (if I can find them at Lowes or HD).

Thanks for the feedback.

Mike

ma

max

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 9:31 PM

24/12/2004 4:36 AM

I had a big one with all of the attachments. I made a lot of drawers with
the half blind dovetail template. Used the 1/4 inch finger joint a lot. Had
the adjustable dovetail set and it worked fine. The biggest problem with all
of these jigs on the market is the simpler the jig the easiest to learn. The
Omni will do a great job but it takes time to learn.
max

> I'm thinking of getting a dovetail jig after the first of the year.
> The PC Omnijig (16 inch) looks good. Any pros and cons from owners
> would be appreciated.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Mike
>

tt

"toller"

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 9:31 PM

25/12/2004 2:32 AM


"MikeK" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 05:42:38 GMT, "toller" <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>>
>>"MikeK" <[email protected]> wrote in message
>>news:[email protected]...
>>> On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 04:42:37 GMT, "toller" <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>
>>>>You have to tell us what you want to use it for! It is well suited for
>>>>somethings, and not so good for others.
>>>>
>>>
>>> Well, I would like to make different kinds of boxes and new kitchen
>>> drawers with it to start. What is it not suited well for.
>>>
>>It would be great for new kitchen drawers. If comes into it's own making
>>a
>>lot of exactly the same standard half blind dovetails; like what your
>>kitchen drawers will need. Though the 16" capacity will be wasted. Maybe
>>a
>>smaller, cheaper, jig will be okay for that also, but none have the
>>reassuring mass of an omnijig. (The 24" weighs 60 pounds; I don't know
>>about
>>the 16".)
>>
>>It is not so good with creative variable stuff. Some of the other, more
>>complicated, jigs do that better.
>>
>
> PC has, or will have soon, a new model 4212 12" deluxe Jig. The PC
> site makes it sound good. I'll wait till I can actually look at the
> 12" deluxe and the 16" Omnijig (if I can find them at Lowes or HD).
>
Yeh, I read the description. It is sheet steel instead of cast aluminum.
Might be as good, or might just be the same as all the cheapies.

Mm

MikeK

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 9:31 PM

23/12/2004 11:32 PM

On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 04:42:37 GMT, "toller" <[email protected]> wrote:

>You have to tell us what you want to use it for! It is well suited for
>somethings, and not so good for others.
>

Well, I would like to make different kinds of boxes and new kitchen
drawers with it to start. What is it not suited well for.

Mike

Mm

MikeK

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 9:31 PM

23/12/2004 11:29 PM

On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 04:36:51 GMT, max <[email protected]> wrote:

>I had a big one with all of the attachments. I made a lot of drawers with
>the half blind dovetail template. Used the 1/4 inch finger joint a lot. Had
>the adjustable dovetail set and it worked fine. The biggest problem with all
>of these jigs on the market is the simpler the jig the easiest to learn. The
>Omni will do a great job but it takes time to learn.
>max
>

Time to learn is no problem. I'll be retiring in June.

Mike

LL

LRod

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 11:29 PM

25/12/2004 4:29 PM

On Sat, 25 Dec 2004 11:12:13 -0500, Bob G.
<[email protected]> wrote:

>.
>>
>>Well, if we're bragging, I've been retired a year longer than you and
>>I'm only 58 (although 59 next month).
>
>No I was not bragging...

I know, but I needed to.

>Plus I find 6 day weekends to be much more enjoyable then 7 day weeks....

Absolutely.

>I know the " lifetime " supply I accumulated before I retired only
>lasted me a few years LOL

I never have acquired a lot of lumber. So I had to brag about
retirement...

- -
LRod

Master Woodbutcher and seasoned termite

Shamelessly whoring my website since 1999

http://www.woodbutcher.net

sS

[email protected] (SteveC1280)

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 11:29 PM

24/12/2004 5:30 PM

Hi Mike,

You'll love retirement. I retired in September (medical problems) and have
made a kitchen table and a jewelry box so far. Nothing but time and stacks of
wood.

Steve
>>
Remove the 'remove' in my address to e:mail me.

BG

Bob G.

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 11:29 PM

24/12/2004 7:40 PM


>Hi Mike,
>
>You'll love retirement. I retired in September (medical problems) and have
>made a kitchen table and a jewelry box so far. Nothing but time and stacks of
>wood.
>
>Steve
I have to comment on your last sentence....

I am now 61...(just had a birthday last week) and I retired the day I
turned 55....

It does NOT take long for those "stacks" of wood to disapear..BELIEVE
ME.... I thought I had enouygh to last forever ... dumb me !

Nor does it take much time before you start to notice you do not have
any ..... (time that is)

Lots of luck....

Bob Griffiths

LL

LRod

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 11:29 PM

25/12/2004 1:08 AM

On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 19:40:34 -0500, Bob G.
<[email protected]> wrote:

>I have to comment on your last sentence....
>
>I am now 61...(just had a birthday last week) and I retired the day I
>turned 55....

Well, if we're bragging, I've been retired a year longer than you and
I'm only 58 (although 59 next month).

- -
LRod

Master Woodbutcher and seasoned termite

Shamelessly whoring my website since 1999

http://www.woodbutcher.net

BG

Bob G.

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 11:29 PM

25/12/2004 11:12 AM

.
>
>Well, if we're bragging, I've been retired a year longer than you and
>I'm only 58 (although 59 next month).
>
>- -
>LRod

No I was not bragging...because I still work one evening a week just
to remine myself why the hell I retired in the first place... Plus I
find 6 day weekends to be much more enjoyable then 7 day weeks....

BUT my main reason was to tell the OP that his "stack" of lumber
will disapear a lot faster then he thinks...

I know the " lifetime " supply I accumulated before I retired only
lasted me a few years LOL

Bob Griffiths.

Mm

MikeK

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 11:29 PM

24/12/2004 4:34 PM

On 24 Dec 2004 17:30:16 GMT, [email protected] (SteveC1280)
wrote:

>Hi Mike,
>
>You'll love retirement. I retired in September (medical problems) and have
>made a kitchen table and a jewelry box so far. Nothing but time and stacks of
>wood.
>
>Steve
>>>
>Remove the 'remove' in my address to e:mail me.

Steve,
I hope to enjoy myself while I can (I'll only be 60 when I retire).
I plan to keep busy in the shop and watching the grandson after
school.

Mike

jJ

[email protected] (JLucas ILS)

in reply to MikeK on 24/12/2004 4:34 PM

26/12/2004 6:59 AM

Mike,
I am almost 68 and am retired and working more than ever before. I have the
best "job" on earth...getting tools to review and use. As to Omnijig, it has no
greater learning curve thatn any of the others.

Mm

MikeK

in reply to MikeK on 24/12/2004 4:34 PM

26/12/2004 3:29 AM

I agree, it isn't very difficult to learn to use a tool. Mastering
it is another issue.

Mike

On 26 Dec 2004 06:59:41 GMT, [email protected] (JLucas ILS) wrote:

>Mike,
> I am almost 68 and am retired and working more than ever before. I have the
>best "job" on earth...getting tools to review and use. As to Omnijig, it has no
>greater learning curve thatn any of the others.

tt

"toller"

in reply to MikeK on 23/12/2004 9:31 PM

24/12/2004 5:42 AM


"MikeK" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> On Fri, 24 Dec 2004 04:42:37 GMT, "toller" <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>>You have to tell us what you want to use it for! It is well suited for
>>somethings, and not so good for others.
>>
>
> Well, I would like to make different kinds of boxes and new kitchen
> drawers with it to start. What is it not suited well for.
>
It would be great for new kitchen drawers. If comes into it's own making a
lot of exactly the same standard half blind dovetails; like what your
kitchen drawers will need. Though the 16" capacity will be wasted. Maybe a
smaller, cheaper, jig will be okay for that also, but none have the
reassuring mass of an omnijig. (The 24" weighs 60 pounds; I don't know about
the 16".)

It is not so good with creative variable stuff. Some of the other, more
complicated, jigs do that better.


You’ve reached the end of replies