m

13/10/2006 6:48 AM

3 inches VS. 4 inches wide Hardwood Flooring

Hi,
Any opinion on 3 VS. 4 inches wide Hardwood Flooring? The 4 inch is
little more expensive and I heard from none woodworker it looks better.
I try to put some Brazilian Cherry and I can get 3 inches wide any time
while 4 inches are special order. Wider wood would cupp more and shrink
more than narrower, but is there any concern for Harwood floor and 1
inch difference?

Thanks
MaxEN


This topic has 5 replies

RA

"Randy A"

in reply to [email protected] on 13/10/2006 6:48 AM

13/10/2006 10:26 PM

I have 4" maple flooring in my house for 2 years, and I haven't had any
problems with it.

<[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Hi,
> Any opinion on 3 VS. 4 inches wide Hardwood Flooring? The 4 inch is
> little more expensive and I heard from none woodworker it looks better.
> I try to put some Brazilian Cherry and I can get 3 inches wide any time
> while 4 inches are special order. Wider wood would cupp more and shrink
> more than narrower, but is there any concern for Harwood floor and 1
> inch difference?
>
> Thanks
> MaxEN
>

f

in reply to [email protected] on 13/10/2006 6:48 AM

13/10/2006 7:51 AM


[email protected] wrote:
> Hi,
> Any opinion on 3 VS. 4 inches wide Hardwood Flooring? The 4 inch is
> little more expensive and I heard from none woodworker it looks better.
> I try to put some Brazilian Cherry and I can get 3 inches wide any time
> while 4 inches are special order. Wider wood would cup more and shrink
> more than narrower, but is there any concern for Harwood floor and 1
> inch difference?
>

I have 4" Red Oak flooring and it seems to cup more than the
I3" flooring. But my Mom has 'random' width oak flooring,
not sure if it is red or white, 3 - 5 inch that has stayed dead flat.

The difference I think is that mine is over an unheated crawlspace,
hers is over a heated basement.

--

FF

Ll

"Locutus"

in reply to [email protected] on 13/10/2006 6:48 AM

13/10/2006 9:56 AM


<[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Hi,
> Any opinion on 3 VS. 4 inches wide Hardwood Flooring? The 4 inch is
> little more expensive and I heard from none woodworker it looks better.
> I try to put some Brazilian Cherry and I can get 3 inches wide any time
> while 4 inches are special order. Wider wood would cupp more and shrink
> more than narrower, but is there any concern for Harwood floor and 1
> inch difference?
>
> Thanks
> MaxEN
>

The only difference is whatever you think looks better.

Ll

"Locutus"

in reply to [email protected] on 13/10/2006 6:48 AM

13/10/2006 10:27 AM


"B A R R Y" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Locutus wrote:
>>
>> The only difference is whatever you think looks better.
>
> I agree. The relief milling on the back of properly made flooring does a
> pretty good job of limiting cupping.
>
> Now, if we're talking 3" vs. 12"... <G>
>

I guess another difference would be *slightly* less installation as the 4"
would cover more. But not really enough difference to factor into the
decision.

BA

B A R R Y

in reply to [email protected] on 13/10/2006 6:48 AM

13/10/2006 2:13 PM

Locutus wrote:
>
> The only difference is whatever you think looks better.
>

I agree. The relief milling on the back of properly made flooring does
a pretty good job of limiting cupping.

Now, if we're talking 3" vs. 12"... <G>


You’ve reached the end of replies