DD

David

14/01/2006 7:32 PM

Are Lie-Nielsen planes...

as uncomfortable in the hand as they appear? Veritas doesn't make every
type of plane I'd like to purchase, and when I look at the images of
the LN planes, they look like they have sharp, unfriendly bodies. I'm
only interested in the rabbet and specialty planes of theirs. I have
all the block, jointer, and jack planes I need.

Dave


This topic has 4 replies

ee

"eganders"

in reply to David on 14/01/2006 7:32 PM

15/01/2006 12:58 PM

I just got the LN 60 1/2R rabbet plane for Christmas. I agree that
some of the LN planes don't look as comfortable as the Lee Valley
planes, but this one seems to be an exception. The top heel section is
rounded and fits in the palm of your hand very nicely. If you opt to
go with this plane, I think you will be happy with it. I was waiting
around to see if Lee Valley was going to come up with one with an
adjustable mouth, but decided not to wait.

GG

"George"

in reply to David on 14/01/2006 7:32 PM

15/01/2006 8:45 AM


"David" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> as uncomfortable in the hand as they appear? Veritas doesn't make every
> type of plane I'd like to purchase, and when I look at the images of the
> LN planes, they look like they have sharp, unfriendly bodies. I'm only
> interested in the rabbet and specialty planes of theirs. I have all the
> block, jointer, and jack planes I need.
>

Their edges are nicely finished, as with the rest of the plane. If you are
ham-handed, you will find the clearances similar to the heritage planes they
imitate. Advantage LV. As to a rabbeting plane, you do have a fence and
the LV shoulder, if you care.


Br

Ba r r y

in reply to David on 14/01/2006 7:32 PM

15/01/2006 12:59 PM

On Sat, 14 Jan 2006 19:32:25 -0800, David <[email protected]> wrote:

>as uncomfortable in the hand as they appear?

I don't own any, but I've tried them in seminars.

They're awesome works of mechanical art. Considering the facts, I
think they're worth what they cost. Of course, I think my Veritas
planes are also awesome, beautiful enough for use, but I can actually
afford them.

I didn't find any LN plane more or less comfortable than any of the
Veritas or old Stanley and Sargent stuff I have.

But then again, I'm no neander...

Barry

Gg

Glen

in reply to David on 14/01/2006 7:32 PM

15/01/2006 11:56 AM

David wrote:
> as uncomfortable in the hand as they appear? Veritas doesn't make every
> type of plane I'd like to purchase, and when I look at the images of
> the LN planes, they look like they have sharp, unfriendly bodies. I'm
> only interested in the rabbet and specialty planes of theirs. I have
> all the block, jointer, and jack planes I need.
>
> Dave
I only have 2 LN, the low angle jack and the large scraper. I have a
few LV as well. Uncomfortable is not a word I would use to describe LN.
Beautiful, excellent, slick, all seem to fit, but uncomfortable? No.

Glen


You’ve reached the end of replies