I was recently at the Woodworks show in Ontario CA. While wandering around
the small show hoping to see the Lee Valley booth in all its glory (more on
this later), I saw the Ridge Carbide booth. I liked what I saw and picked
up a TS-2000 blade. I had some Walnut to rip so loaded up the TS-2000.
Using it was great. It cut better/smother than my Forrest (freshly
sharpened) and as well as my custom made blade. All-in-all, a very nice
blade.
As for Lee Valley, their booth did disappoint me. They had nothing for sale
and delivery on site, only catalog orders with free shipping. But what the
heck, I ordered a router plane and a few other goodies.
Man do I wish Robin would open a store in SoCal! (Maybe he will franchise
on and I'll open it here!)
Dave
"JGS"
> Hi Dave,
> As to the saw blade vs the Forrest, do you remember what you paid? And was
> the
> blade sharpened by Forrest? Thanks, JG
>
It was $88.00. Yes, the Forrest was a sharpened at Forrest.
Just for kicks, I pulled a second brand new Forrest WW2 from the shelve,
loaded it up and ripped the same piece. Results were the same. The Ridge
Carbide cut polished clean edge and the WW2 did an very nice job as well.
Under close inspection of both blades, the RC blade does have larger carbide
teeth. This will allow for more sharpening but other than that, they seem
to be of equal quality. However, I returned the RC blade to the saw for
more use.
Dave
I agree. However, it was a factory re-sharpening and I also tested it
against a second, new WW2.
Let me say that I don't know anyone at Ridge Carbide or have an axe to grind
against Forrest. As far as I'm concerened, I just happy to have found
another blade supplier that produces a high quality blade for a reasonable
cost. My custom made blades still do the lion's share of cutting although I
did put the RC blade back into the saw and will give it a long, hard test
drive.
Dave
"Leon" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>I am not doubting your conclusions but remember that a blade that is simply
>resharpened may not be completely brought back to factory specs. I always
>have my blades reflattened when resharpened. If the Forrest is not running
>true anymore it could be "out done" by a B&D lifted off the stack of 100 at
>the borg.
>
> "Teamcasa" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
>>I was recently at the Woodworks show in Ontario CA. While wandering
>>around the small show hoping to see the Lee Valley booth in all its glory
>>(more on this later), I saw the Ridge Carbide booth. I liked what I saw
>>and picked up a TS-2000 blade. I had some Walnut to rip so loaded up the
>>TS-2000. Using it was great. It cut better/smother than my Forrest
>>(freshly sharpened) and as well as my custom made blade. All-in-all, a
>>very nice blade.
>>
>> As for Lee Valley, their booth did disappoint me. They had nothing for
>> sale and delivery on site, only catalog orders with free shipping. But
>> what the heck, I ordered a router plane and a few other goodies.
>>
>> Man do I wish Robin would open a store in SoCal! (Maybe he will
>> franchise on and I'll open it here!)
>>
>> Dave
>>
>
>
First time posting via Google (don't ask), so I don't know if this will
be a bottom or top post. Ah well...
FWIW, I have had a Ridge Carbide blade for about three years and a
Forrest II for about 2 years. They seem to perform the same. Happy
with both. I also bought the RC blade at a woodworking show for about
the same $(I think, poor memory) as Dave.
I've sent the RC blade to Ridge for sharpening but haven't tried it
since I got it back.
Bill Leonhardt
Leon,
> Either way I am happy to know about your findings with the Ridge blade in
> case I become less enchanted with Forrest.
Agreed. Sometimes its nice to know we have more options.
Enchanted Forrest! Whew. Almost missed that one!
Dave
Posted Via Usenet.com Premium Usenet Newsgroup Services
----------------------------------------------------------
** SPEED ** RETENTION ** COMPLETION ** ANONYMITY **
----------------------------------------------------------
http://www.usenet.com
Hi Dave,
As to the saw blade vs the Forrest, do you remember what you paid? And was the
blade sharpened by Forrest? Thanks, JG
Teamcasa wrote:
> I was recently at the Woodworks show in Ontario CA. While wandering around
> the small show hoping to see the Lee Valley booth in all its glory (more on
> this later), I saw the Ridge Carbide booth. I liked what I saw and picked
> up a TS-2000 blade. I had some Walnut to rip so loaded up the TS-2000.
> Using it was great. It cut better/smother than my Forrest (freshly
> sharpened) and as well as my custom made blade. All-in-all, a very nice
> blade.
>
> As for Lee Valley, their booth did disappoint me. They had nothing for sale
> and delivery on site, only catalog orders with free shipping. But what the
> heck, I ordered a router plane and a few other goodies.
>
> Man do I wish Robin would open a store in SoCal! (Maybe he will franchise
> on and I'll open it here!)
>
> Dave
"Teamcasa" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>I agree. However, it was a factory re-sharpening and I also tested it
>against a second, new WW2.
Understood, My point was not to condemn your findings and I understand you
feelings. Factory sharpened by Forrest does not necessarily mean that the
blade will be flattened or cut like new. IF the blade is not flat,
resharpening is not going to improve the cut to factory specs regardless of
who resharpens it. IIRC you have to request for the blade to be
reflattened in addition to resharpening or simply ask that the blade be
brought back to factory specs, and hope that UPS does not bend it on the way
home. LOL
Either way I am happy to know about your findings with the Ridge blade in
case I become less enchanted with Forrest.
I am not doubting your conclusions but remember that a blade that is simply
resharpened may not be completely brought back to factory specs. I always
have my blades reflattened when resharpened. If the Forrest is not running
true anymore it could be "out done" by a B&D lifted off the stack of 100 at
the borg.
"Teamcasa" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>I was recently at the Woodworks show in Ontario CA. While wandering around
>the small show hoping to see the Lee Valley booth in all its glory (more on
>this later), I saw the Ridge Carbide booth. I liked what I saw and picked
>up a TS-2000 blade. I had some Walnut to rip so loaded up the TS-2000.
>Using it was great. It cut better/smother than my Forrest (freshly
>sharpened) and as well as my custom made blade. All-in-all, a very nice
>blade.
>
> As for Lee Valley, their booth did disappoint me. They had nothing for
> sale and delivery on site, only catalog orders with free shipping. But
> what the heck, I ordered a router plane and a few other goodies.
>
> Man do I wish Robin would open a store in SoCal! (Maybe he will franchise
> on and I'll open it here!)
>
> Dave
>
"Teamcasa" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> "JGS"
>> Hi Dave,
>> As to the saw blade vs the Forrest, do you remember what you paid? And
>> was the
>> blade sharpened by Forrest? Thanks, JG
>>
> It was $88.00. Yes, the Forrest was a sharpened at Forrest.
> Just for kicks, I pulled a second brand new Forrest WW2 from the shelve,
> loaded it up and ripped the same piece. Results were the same. The Ridge
> Carbide cut polished clean edge and the WW2 did an very nice job as well.
I bought a Ridge Carbide a couple of years ago at a show. They had a very
good deal on the 40T combo and an 8" dado blade. I don't recall the cost,
but it was a saving of well over $50. In comparison tests a few years
back, American Woodworker gave them an Editors Choice.