NE

"Never Enough Money"

05/08/2005 1:48 PM

Compare Bosch Colt Palm Router to Porter-Cable Model 100

Anyone have a good comparison? How about you, Pat Warner?

I recently posted about the Bosch Colt Palm router and it sounds like a
great little machine. So before I buy it, which wil be soon, let me
leave no stone unturned and ask about the PC Model 100.

I over-analyze everything......


This topic has 4 replies

NE

"Never Enough Money"

in reply to "Never Enough Money" on 05/08/2005 1:48 PM

05/08/2005 7:29 PM

Well, I went to the supermarket to buy a Fine Homebuilding. Either the
issue you refer to is last months or it hasn't hit the newstands yet.
The issue I saw has a cover of laying tile and reviews biscuit joiners.

I called my public library and they do not subscribe to Fine
Homebuilding.

Perhaps you could just tell me the results.

Rd

Robatoy

in reply to "Never Enough Money" on 05/08/2005 1:48 PM

05/08/2005 6:53 PM

In article <[email protected]>,
"Never Enough Money" <[email protected]> wrote:

> Anyone have a good comparison? How about you, Pat Warner?
>
> I recently posted about the Bosch Colt Palm router and it sounds like a
> great little machine. So before I buy it, which wil be soon, let me
> leave no stone unturned and ask about the PC Model 100.
>
> I over-analyze everything......

I bought a couple of Ridgid laminate trimmers. I use one as a trimmer,
the other as a small router for round-over bits etc. They came with
excellent guides and the base-plate takes PC-type bushings.
I have gone through quite a few other trim-routers, including Bosch, PC
and Makita and prefer the Ridgids. I cannot comment on longevity as I
have only had them for about 3 months. I almost forgot to mention that
they soft-start and are variable speed, light, and the waist-line is
small enough for single handed grip.
If they have a decent life expectancy they're winners in my book.

I have no affiliation with Home Depot, in fact, I'm not crazy about
them.... but credit due where credit is due, I always say...well, not
always, but when I think about it I say it.

BM

"Bob Mejerle"

in reply to "Never Enough Money" on 05/08/2005 1:48 PM

05/08/2005 8:46 PM

Take a look at the current Fine Homebuilding. They reviewed several
laminate trimmers, including the Bosch Colt Palm router.


"Never Enough Money" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Anyone have a good comparison? How about you, Pat Warner?
>
> I recently posted about the Bosch Colt Palm router and it sounds like a
> great little machine. So before I buy it, which wil be soon, let me
> leave no stone unturned and ask about the PC Model 100.
>
> I over-analyze everything......
>

BM

"Bob Mejerle"

in reply to "Never Enough Money" on 05/08/2005 1:48 PM

06/08/2005 9:05 PM

My appology..... In fact, the review was in Tools of the Trade. I'm
looking at the article now, it's in the July/August 2005 issue, page 43.

The review included the Bosch PR20EVS, Dewalt DW673K, Makita 3708FC,
Porter-Cable 97310, and the Rigid R2400. The bottom-line, is that the
reviewer(s) liked the Porter-Cable if your doing a lot of laminate work.
However, for odd-job routing and laminate work, they preferred the Bosch
with the Rigid coming in second. They had mixed emotions about the Makita.

To paraphrase the reviewer comments; The Bosch was very popular with the
crew. They felt that the router was more versative with the variable speed
control. Everyone was impressed with the base, liked the soft-start
feature, and the visibility was good.


"Never Enough Money" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Well, I went to the supermarket to buy a Fine Homebuilding. Either the
> issue you refer to is last months or it hasn't hit the newstands yet.
> The issue I saw has a cover of laying tile and reviews biscuit joiners.
>
> I called my public library and they do not subscribe to Fine
> Homebuilding.
>
> Perhaps you could just tell me the results.
>


You’ve reached the end of replies