BW

Bill Wichser

11/01/2005 4:24 PM

Brads, finish nails, and staples - advice

Can anyone suggest where I would use one type of fastener in place of
another? I've just acquired a pneumatic nailer and stapler and am
confused by all of the choices I now have.

Also are there recommended lengths? Obviously the fastener needs to
protrude past the first component but how deep into the other should I
be aiming to achieve?

Thanks,

Bill


This topic has 9 replies

mm

"mp"

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

11/01/2005 8:18 PM

> Can anyone suggest where I would use one type of fastener in place of
> another? I've just acquired a pneumatic nailer and stapler and am
> confused by all of the choices I now have.

Brads are used when you want to hold something together while the glue dries
or for attaching lighter weight mouldings. Brad nails are available up to 2"
in length. Finish nails are heavier guage, and of course leave a larger
hole, and come in lengths up to 2.5". These are useful for heavier crown
moulding, door and window casings, etc. Brad nails are 18ga, and finish
nails are 15 or 16 ga. The thicker shank in finish nails is less likely to
be deflected by the grain direction in hardwoods.

Crown staples have good holding power and are usefull for thin materials or
materials that are soft or tear easy, where brad nails can easily pull
through, such as mdf, and masonite or luan commonly used for cabinet backs.
1/4" crown staples are readily available in sizes up to 1.5" or so.

mm

"mp"

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

12/01/2005 9:56 AM

>> ... Finish nails are heavier guage...and come in lengths up to 2.5". ...
>
> Good description...minor nit--finish nails come in standard sizes up to
> 16d

Yes, but the OP was referring to supplies for air nailers.

j

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

11/01/2005 1:35 PM


Bill Wichser wrote:
> Can anyone suggest where I would use one type of fastener in place of

> another? I've just acquired a pneumatic nailer and stapler and am
> confused by all of the choices I now have.
>
> Also are there recommended lengths? Obviously the fastener needs to
> protrude past the first component but how deep into the other should
I
> be aiming to achieve?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Bill

I'd imagine this info applies to brads as well as it does to screws:
Totals fastener length = 3X thickness of thinner material.

http://www.mcfeelys.com/length.asp

Short answer, as deep as possible, unless you are intending them to
come apart.

For example, when nailing a 3/4 to a 3/4, I use the "Add them together
and subtract a bit" rule: 3/4 + 3/4 - 1/8 = 1 3/8. However, when is 3/4
really 3/4 (if store bought)? And, when is your brad nailer not going
to counter sink a bit? Use 1 1/4" :)

Jay

tT

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

12/01/2005 12:27 AM

Bill wrote:>Can anyone suggest where I would use one type of fastener in place
of
>another? I've just acquired a pneumatic nailer and stapler and am
>confused by all of the choices I now have.
>
>Also are there recommended lengths? Obviously the fastener needs to
>protrude past the first component but how deep into the other should I
>be aiming to achieve?
>
>Thanks,
>
>Bill
>
>
One-half inch. I'd use the stapler where the fasteners won't be apparent, such
as backsides 'n such. There ya go. Tom
Work at your leisure!

DB

Duane Bozarth

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

12/01/2005 9:43 AM

mp wrote:
>
...
> ... Finish nails are heavier guage...and come in lengths up to 2.5". ...

Good description...minor nit--finish nails come in standard sizes up to
16d

DB

Duane Bozarth

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

12/01/2005 12:34 PM

mp wrote:
>
> >> ... Finish nails are heavier guage...and come in lengths up to 2.5". ...
> >
> > Good description...minor nit--finish nails come in standard sizes up to
> > 16d
>
> Yes, but the OP was referring to supplies for air nailers.

Ahhhh...I missed that.

DD

David

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

11/01/2005 1:36 PM

The stapler is used for fastenening thin to thick, such as 1/4 or 1/8
backs to cabinets. Nailers are used for pretty much anything Norm builds.

David

Bill Wichser wrote:

> Can anyone suggest where I would use one type of fastener in place of
> another? I've just acquired a pneumatic nailer and stapler and am
> confused by all of the choices I now have.
>
> Also are there recommended lengths? Obviously the fastener needs to
> protrude past the first component but how deep into the other should I
> be aiming to achieve?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Bill

Kk

KS

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

11/01/2005 10:18 PM

In article <[email protected]>,
[email protected] says...
>
> Bill Wichser wrote:
> > Can anyone suggest where I would use one type of fastener in place of
>
> > another? I've just acquired a pneumatic nailer and stapler and am
> > confused by all of the choices I now have.
> >
> > Also are there recommended lengths? Obviously the fastener needs to
> > protrude past the first component but how deep into the other should
> I
> > be aiming to achieve?
> >
> > Thanks,
> >
> > Bill
>
> I'd imagine this info applies to brads as well as it does to screws:
> Totals fastener length = 3X thickness of thinner material.
>
> http://www.mcfeelys.com/length.asp
>
> Short answer, as deep as possible, unless you are intending them to
> come apart.
>
> For example, when nailing a 3/4 to a 3/4, I use the "Add them together
> and subtract a bit" rule: 3/4 + 3/4 - 1/8 = 1 3/8. However, when is 3/4
> really 3/4 (if store bought)? And, when is your brad nailer not going
> to counter sink a bit? Use 1 1/4" :)
>
> Jay
>
>
I normally use the same rule. However, the more critical the
depth/length of nail the more likely I have one or two longer nails left
in the gun from last time that I didn't see before I loaded in the
"correct" length nails this time.

BW

Bill Wichser

in reply to Bill Wichser on 11/01/2005 4:24 PM

12/01/2005 2:13 PM

Thanks to all who responded. I think I have it now and can comfortably
proceed with the little bit of knowledge I now have.

To summarize:

Brads are for tacking "while the glue sets up" as well as for small
mouldings.

Finish nails are for the bigger "stuff" like crown moulding and window
casings where they provide some structural support.

Staples are for thin material like cabinet backs.

As for length, it is best to go as deep as possible but not less than
half an inch.

Once again this forum has provided information which is timely and
invaluable.

Bill


You’ve reached the end of replies