DP

"Dennis Poff"

21/02/2007 1:48 PM

Which Wood

Hello Group,

I'm new to woodworking, but I want to form an Ankh out of wood (where
my computer should be placed in). So the foot and the arms of the ankh
should be made hollow and carved out with a chisel. (I know it's gonna
be hard, but I want to try it anyway, plus I have to start with something,
which interests me.)

My question is which wood would suit best for the task. From a friend
I've heard that birch would be too hard for a chisel, so is there any
better, which is also easily available at the local markets.

Finally I wanted to ask if I should use dryed, chemical treated or
natural wood.

Thanks in Advance
Dennis





This topic has 11 replies

b

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

21/02/2007 10:09 AM

well, since you don't say where you are, I can't say what will be
available in your local market.

but since what you are asking about is carveability, I can recommend,
in no particular order, basswood, mahogany (the real stuff), poplar,
oak, walnut,

avoid woods with stringy grain like fir, ash, most pine, alder, and
woods with a high mineral content like ipe, apatong or teak.


no wood is too hard to be carved. however, the harder the wood the
more of a workout it will be... it's worth it though. a medium-hard
tight grained wood like birch makes a durable carving that takes nice
crisp detail. the king of woods for carving is lignum vitae, which is
one of the hardest woods on the planet.

the bottom line though is that your project won't use a lot of wood.
get some of what you have available in your local market and have a
try.

keeping your tools sharp will be a lot more important to success than
selecting the exact right wood.

dp

"damian penney"

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

21/02/2007 10:12 AM

On Feb 21, 4:48 am, "Dennis Poff" <[email protected]> wrote:
> Hello Group,
>
> I'm new to woodworking, but I want to form an Ankh out of wood (where
> my computer should be placed in). So the foot and the arms of the ankh
> should be made hollow and carved out with a chisel. (I know it's gonna
> be hard, but I want to try it anyway, plus I have to start with something,
> which interests me.)
>
> My question is which wood would suit best for the task. From a friend
> I've heard that birch would be too hard for a chisel, so is there any
> better, which is also easily available at the local markets.
>
> Finally I wanted to ask if I should use dryed, chemical treated or
> natural wood.
>
> Thanks in Advance
> Dennis

To be honest I think that this project isn't suited to a beginner. I'd
try something easier so as not to be disillusioned.

b

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

25/02/2007 11:11 AM

On Feb 22, 9:51 am, "Dennis Poff" <[email protected]> wrote:

> The thing I noticed is, that the woodwork depends on the sharpness of my
> chisel, which is new. But what do I do, if the tool get's blunt. Is there an
> easy way to sharpen it (like a special stone or something else). How do you
> sharpen your tools?


welcome to the slippery slope.

do a search in this group for "scary sharp"

Bi

Bill in Detroit

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

24/02/2007 12:56 AM

Leuf wrote:

> Oh dear. Just getting that chisel sharp is an adventure you aren't
> prepared for :)
>
> Since you're going to paint it I would suggest that you try making it
> out of MDF. Stack it up out of layers, you can cut each layer out
> with a jig saw or coping saw. You can probably reuse the parts you
> cut out in other areas. Then smooth the outside with a combination of
> work with a rasp/file and sanding. I would probably then go over it
> with bondo and sand again before painting.
>
> Be sure to allow lots of ventilation for the motherboard and hard
> drives. And don't forget about the power supply either. And EMI
> shielding and grounding.
>
>
> -Leuf

While he's at it, he might want to arrange for a little ventilation for
himself, as well. Looks like he might be raising quite a cloud of MDF
dust before he even gets to the bondo part.

If he's gonna go this (otherwise sane) route, he'll need to pick up a
decent respirator on the way out of the lumber yard or auto supply store.

Bill


--
I am disillusioned enough to know that no man's opinion on any subject
is worth a **** unless backed up with enough genuine information to make
him really know what he's talking about.

H. P. Lovecraft


---
avast! Antivirus: Outbound message clean.
Virus Database (VPS): 000716-3, 02/23/2007
Tested on: 2/24/2007 12:56:44 AM
avast! - copyright (c) 1988-2007 ALWIL Software.
http://www.avast.com


DP

"Dennis Poff"

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

22/02/2007 2:34 PM

Thanks for the answers so far. I know this will be a tough project - I'm 28
and so I don't have time to make something easier first ;) - and that's why
I divide it in parts:

1. The foot (ca. 40 x 40 cm)
basically a rectangle, where the motherboard should be placed in.
2. The arms
That's where my drives should be placed in.
3. The head
Decoration only.

At the end, these parts are fitted on top of each other and all of it will
be painted. Maybe it's also possible to make the rectangles out of plates,
but I want to try the carving process anyway (if carving is too difficult,
i'll make plates and add them together for the rectangle). Is there an
electrical device which would aid me in the carving process (the hole of the
foot would be a rather big) and isn't that expensive?

Cheers
Dennis

DP

"Dennis Poff"

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

22/02/2007 5:51 PM

Yes, that's what I want to do, but I don't want wood which costs serveral
thousand dollars ;) Additionally I want to make a hole inside the block so
that I can stuff my computer equipment inside. In the afternoon I tested the
whole thing with old wood (don't know which) and a chisel, and to my
surprise it was relativly easy. So I'm confident that I can do it.

The thing I noticed is, that the woodwork depends on the sharpness of my
chisel, which is new. But what do I do, if the tool get's blunt. Is there an
easy way to sharpen it (like a special stone or something else). How do you
sharpen your tools?

Cheers
Dennis

JC

J. Clarke

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

22/02/2007 8:36 AM

On Thu, 22 Feb 2007 12:24:43 +0000 (UTC), Bruce Barnett
<[email protected]> wrote:

>"Dennis Poff" <[email protected]> writes:
>
>> Hello Group,
>>
>> I'm new to woodworking, but I want to form an Ankh out of wood (where
>> my computer should be placed in). So the foot and the arms of the ankh
>> should be made hollow and carved out with a chisel.
>
>How big will the Ankh be?
>How big is your computer?
>
>Using a chisel to cut out a large hole is very difficult.
>
>Also - you may need a solid piece of wood. (or else you have to join
>the wood together.) This is also difficult. We may be talking about
>sculpture-sized blocks of wood. This is more expensive.

I suspect that <http://www.jarrahwood.com> could fix him up with an
adequate piece, for a price.

AB

Andrew Barss

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

24/02/2007 6:54 PM

Dennis Poff <[email protected]> wrote:
: Hello Group,

: I'm new to woodworking, but I want to form an Ankh out of wood (where
: my computer should be placed in). So the foot and the arms of the ankh
: should be made hollow and carved out with a chisel. (I know it's gonna
: be hard, but I want to try it anyway, plus I have to start with something,
: which interests me.)

: My question is which wood would suit best for the task. From a friend
: I've heard that birch would be too hard for a chisel, so is there any
: better, which is also easily available at the local markets.

Based on what you've asked here, and the later post about sharpening,
I don't think wood is the right medium. You're going to paint it anyway,
so why no use papier-mache? Much less work, tools needed are minimal, and
it would take less time and work just fine.


-- Andy Barss

Ll

Leuf

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

22/02/2007 2:13 PM

On Thu, 22 Feb 2007 17:51:00 +0100, "Dennis Poff" <[email protected]>
wrote:

>Yes, that's what I want to do, but I don't want wood which costs serveral
>thousand dollars ;) Additionally I want to make a hole inside the block so
>that I can stuff my computer equipment inside. In the afternoon I tested the
>whole thing with old wood (don't know which) and a chisel, and to my
>surprise it was relativly easy. So I'm confident that I can do it.
>
>The thing I noticed is, that the woodwork depends on the sharpness of my
>chisel, which is new. But what do I do, if the tool get's blunt. Is there an
>easy way to sharpen it (like a special stone or something else). How do you
>sharpen your tools?

Oh dear. Just getting that chisel sharp is an adventure you aren't
prepared for :)

Since you're going to paint it I would suggest that you try making it
out of MDF. Stack it up out of layers, you can cut each layer out
with a jig saw or coping saw. You can probably reuse the parts you
cut out in other areas. Then smooth the outside with a combination of
work with a rasp/file and sanding. I would probably then go over it
with bondo and sand again before painting.

Be sure to allow lots of ventilation for the motherboard and hard
drives. And don't forget about the power supply either. And EMI
shielding and grounding.


-Leuf

JC

J. Clarke

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

22/02/2007 10:06 AM

On Thu, 22 Feb 2007 14:34:17 +0100, "Dennis Poff" <[email protected]>
wrote:

>Thanks for the answers so far. I know this will be a tough project - I'm 28
>and so I don't have time to make something easier first ;) - and that's why
>I divide it in parts:
>
>1. The foot (ca. 40 x 40 cm)
>basically a rectangle, where the motherboard should be placed in.
>2. The arms
>That's where my drives should be placed in.
>3. The head
>Decoration only.
>
>At the end, these parts are fitted on top of each other and all of it will
>be painted. Maybe it's also possible to make the rectangles out of plates,
>but I want to try the carving process anyway (if carving is too difficult,
>i'll make plates and add them together for the rectangle). Is there an
>electrical device which would aid me in the carving process (the hole of the
>foot would be a rather big) and isn't that expensive?

Whoa, stop. I'm sensing confusion over terminology here.

When a woodworker uses the word "carve" he is generally talking about
a form of sculpture (either that or serving a roast).

Do you really want to start with a block of wood that weighs several
hundred pounds and costs a thousand dollars or more and take a hammer
and chisel and pound on it until you have it in the shape you want?

If so, _why_?








BB

Bruce Barnett

in reply to "Dennis Poff" on 21/02/2007 1:48 PM

22/02/2007 12:24 PM

"Dennis Poff" <[email protected]> writes:

> Hello Group,
>
> I'm new to woodworking, but I want to form an Ankh out of wood (where
> my computer should be placed in). So the foot and the arms of the ankh
> should be made hollow and carved out with a chisel.

How big will the Ankh be?
How big is your computer?

Using a chisel to cut out a large hole is very difficult.

Also - you may need a solid piece of wood. (or else you have to join
the wood together.) This is also difficult. We may be talking about
sculpture-sized blocks of wood. This is more expensive.

--
Sending unsolicited commercial e-mail to this account incurs a fee of
$500 per message, and acknowledges the legality of this contract.


You’ve reached the end of replies