Dg

"Dica"

27/04/2005 10:05 AM

do i need pressure treated wood if i'm staining it anyhow?

i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated wood?
if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
canada, so douglas fir?


This topic has 18 replies

DD

David

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 7:36 AM

yes, you can stain it. I've done that myself.

Dave

Dica wrote:

> "David" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
>
>>oh, one more thing. Staining doesn't provide any benefits equal to the
>>properties of PT wood.
>>
>>Dave
>
>
> thanks dave. so staining won't deter termites? if i do go with pressure
> treated, can i stain it?
>
>>Dica wrote:
>>
>>
>>>i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated
>
> wood?
>
>>>if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
>>>canada, so douglas fir?
>>>
>>>
>
>
>

Tu

"TaskMule"

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 2:48 PM


"Dica" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> "David" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
> > oh, one more thing. Staining doesn't provide any benefits equal to the
> > properties of PT wood.
> >
> > Dave

Keep in mind that Canadian pressure trested wood is not like that found in
the US.
Can. pressure treated wood is usually spruce, which does not pressure treat
properly, and usually of poor quality. It also rots fairly quickly.

Your best bet is western red cedar, usually available at good Ontario lumber
yards.

Pn

Prometheus

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

29/04/2005 5:25 AM

On Wed, 27 Apr 2005 23:18:33 +0800, Old Nick
<[email protected]> wrote:

>In article <[email protected]>, [email protected]
>says...
>
>Maybe use red cedar? It has natural camphor (?) content.
>
>Or use another wood that stands the elemsnts (usually hardwoods), but
>use stirrups to stand the columns up from the ground. SOP over here in
>West Oz, where TermiteZ RULE man! <G>
>
>PT tends to be evil stuff. It will exude poison to people touching it,
>and I am concerned about the long-term effects of getting rid of
>quantities of something that has a 50 year _guarantee_ against rotting!
>Nice idea, but the usual eco-problems.

Could be just me, but when I build structures, I only just PT wood for
sill plates- not the whole thing. If someone is spending enough time
laying on the ground touching the piece of timber *under* the framed
structure, they've probably already got more problems than poison from
PT lumber is likely to cause. On the other hand, your naturally
decay-resistant woods are likely to look better, and if it makes you
happy, go for that option. As far as I know, Cedar, Redwood, Mahogany
and Teak top that list.


>> i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated wood?
>> if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
>> canada, so douglas fir?
>>
>>
>>

Aut inveniam viam aut faciam

Pn

Phisherman

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 9:06 PM

Stain won't protect wood from insect damage. You could use cedar,
redwood, teak, cypress, possibly white oak. Pressure treated wood is
often saturated with moisture. When I use PT wood, I will dry it,
stickered and clamped, for several weeks. As it dries, it tends to
wane, twist, and bow. Wet wood does not stain nor take finish well.
Douglas fir is not a good choice.

On Wed, 27 Apr 2005 10:05:07 -0400, "Dica" <[email protected]>
wrote:

>i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated wood?
>if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
>canada, so douglas fir?
>

Sa

"Steven and Gail Peterson"

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 11:17 PM


"Edwin Pawlowski" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:OVNbe.2296$oD6.242@trndny07...
>
> "David" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
>> yes, you can stain it. I've done that myself.
>>
>> Dave
>
> IIRC, you should wait some period of time before doing so that stain will
> adhere properly.
>
When does the period of time start? When you buy the PT wood, or when you
get around to using it?

Steve

Ww

WillR

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 10:16 AM

Dica wrote:
> i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated wood?
> if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
> canada, so douglas fir?
>
>


Cedar, Ipe etc.

PT will work - I have used it -- don't don't like the chemicals. People
do stain it. I think you can get green and maybe there is a non-green PT
wood here. Local building supply usually has answers...

Not Fir unless treated...

Call Century wood, A&M wood or similar and ask for a recommendation.

Look here for a couple of wood suppliers...
http://woodwork.pmccl.com/Business/linksbusiness.htm



--
Will
Occasional Techno-geek

DD

David

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 7:26 AM

PT wood is used primarily to deter termites. Wood in contact with the
ground should be PT. Above ground you can go with non-PT. Fir isn't
going to last long when exposed to the elements. Redwood would be be
better, but that might be an option for you. How about cedar instead?
That's the usual wood when redwood is not available or too expensive in
your area.

Dave

Dica wrote:

> i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated wood?
> if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
> canada, so douglas fir?
>
>

DD

David

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 7:27 AM

oh, one more thing. Staining doesn't provide any benefits equal to the
properties of PT wood.

Dave

Dica wrote:

> i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated wood?
> if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
> canada, so douglas fir?
>
>

ON

Old Nick

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 11:18 PM

In article <[email protected]>, [email protected]
says...

Maybe use red cedar? It has natural camphor (?) content.

Or use another wood that stands the elemsnts (usually hardwoods), but
use stirrups to stand the columns up from the ground. SOP over here in
West Oz, where TermiteZ RULE man! <G>

PT tends to be evil stuff. It will exude poison to people touching it,
and I am concerned about the long-term effects of getting rid of
quantities of something that has a 50 year _guarantee_ against rotting!
Nice idea, but the usual eco-problems.

> i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated wood?
> if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
> canada, so douglas fir?
>
>
>

ON

Old Nick

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

28/04/2005 5:39 PM

In article <[email protected]>,
[email protected] says...

shrug. Sorry Dica

> Bugs, chemicals and laws differ greatly around the world.
>
> Good luck with your project. Take pictures to share.
>
> Patriarch
>

ON

Old Nick

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

28/04/2005 5:39 PM

In article <[email protected]>,
[email protected] says...

shrug. Sorry Dica

> Bugs, chemicals and laws differ greatly around the world.
>
> Good luck with your project. Take pictures to share.
>
> Patriarch
>

EP

"Edwin Pawlowski"

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 3:08 PM


"David" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> yes, you can stain it. I've done that myself.
>
> Dave

IIRC, you should wait some period of time before doing so that stain will
adhere properly.

Dg

"Dica"

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 10:34 AM

"David" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> oh, one more thing. Staining doesn't provide any benefits equal to the
> properties of PT wood.
>
> Dave

thanks dave. so staining won't deter termites? if i do go with pressure
treated, can i stain it?
>
> Dica wrote:
>
> > i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated
wood?
> > if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
> > canada, so douglas fir?
> >
> >

Dg

"Dica"

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 11:41 AM


"Old Nick" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> In article <[email protected]>, [email protected]
> says...
>
> Maybe use red cedar? It has natural camphor (?) content.
>
> Or use another wood that stands the elemsnts (usually hardwoods), but
> use stirrups to stand the columns up from the ground. SOP over here in
> West Oz, where TermiteZ RULE man! <G>
>
> PT tends to be evil stuff. It will exude poison to people touching it,

if i stain it, is there some kind of sealer i can use that will keep the
chemicals from bleeding through?

> and I am concerned about the long-term effects of getting rid of
> quantities of something that has a 50 year _guarantee_ against rotting!
> Nice idea, but the usual eco-problems.
>
> > i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated
wood?
> > if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
> > canada, so douglas fir?
> >
> >
> >

DD

David

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 7:40 AM

Copper napthanate will deter those buggers for a short time, but is not
effective in the long term. I've gotten gallons of that stuff at Home
Depot. It stinks to high heaven and will remain oily for days, when
applied liberally to wood. Don't rely on C.N. to protect your wood from
decay.

Dave

Dica wrote:

> "David" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
>
>>oh, one more thing. Staining doesn't provide any benefits equal to the
>>properties of PT wood.
>>
>>Dave
>
>
> thanks dave. so staining won't deter termites? if i do go with pressure
> treated, can i stain it?
>
>>Dica wrote:
>>
>>
>>>i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated
>
> wood?
>
>>>if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
>>>canada, so douglas fir?
>>>
>>>
>
>
>

JQ

"Jason Quick"

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

28/04/2005 2:52 AM

"Phisherman" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Pressure treated wood is
> often saturated with moisture.

And "saturated" is the correct word in spades. That stuff is *wet*. I'm
surprised it doesn't drip when you make a fresh cut.

> When I use PT wood, I will dry it,
> stickered and clamped, for several weeks. As it dries, it tends to
> wane, twist, and bow.

Built a deck out of the new PT lumber coupla years back. What an utter pain
in the ass it was to work with and on, and hardly worth the trouble to make
it look decent. Though after about a year of exposure, it stained up okay
with a cedar-tone stain from Pittsburgh Paints. Still, next time I build a
deck, I'm going with something - anything - else.

I picked up some ipe stock last week and caught myself thinking a deck made
of ipe 2x2s would look pretty cool. That said, next time I might go with
cedar or cypress due to cost, unless some other alternative (cumaru?) is
available more cheaply.

Jason

Pg

Patriarch

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 2:36 PM

"Dica" <[email protected]> wrote in
news:[email protected]:

<snip>

> if i stain it, is there some kind of sealer i can use that will keep
> the chemicals from bleeding through?
>

Several of your fellow Canadians have recommended quality local suppliers.
Go have a chat with them about local requirements, practices and products.
What David does in California works here, and the Aussies know Oz, but you
need an experienced Canadian supplier.

Bugs, chemicals and laws differ greatly around the world.

Good luck with your project. Take pictures to share.

Patriarch

DD

David

in reply to "Dica" on 27/04/2005 10:05 AM

27/04/2005 9:34 AM

I whole heartedly agree that PT should not be used where anyone would
come in contact with it. Splinters can be quite nasty due to the
chemicals. don't use in a children's playground area.

Dave

Old Nick wrote:

> In article <[email protected]>, [email protected]
> says...
>
> Maybe use red cedar? It has natural camphor (?) content.
>
> Or use another wood that stands the elemsnts (usually hardwoods), but
> use stirrups to stand the columns up from the ground. SOP over here in
> West Oz, where TermiteZ RULE man! <G>
>
> PT tends to be evil stuff. It will exude poison to people touching it,
> and I am concerned about the long-term effects of getting rid of
> quantities of something that has a 50 year _guarantee_ against rotting!
> Nice idea, but the usual eco-problems.
>
>
>>i'm building an arbor and plan to stain it. do i need pressure treated wood?
>>if so, can i still stain it? if not, what kind of wood? i'm in ontario,
>>canada, so douglas fir?
>>
>>
>>


You’ve reached the end of replies